0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 129662 times.
Thank Ted! I probably would not be ordering this piece with your assistance.
I'm gonna take that as a compliment.
Well, I finally have had a chance to evaluate 'The Music Vault N.A.S.' from Neal at Sound Science - www.sound sciencecat.com.The Music Vault is essentially a music server, meant to be used with the Slim Devices Squeeze Box, Duet or Transporter.The 'Music Vault' consists of a motherboard running Linux OS, 1TB drive, (enough to hold about 1500 CDs ripped via FLAC), CD drive and wireless card.I used the device connected via ethernet to my router and established the Music Vault as a network point on the workgroup that also includes my laptop and desktop PC. In this configuration, the Music Vault was able to download CD data from the internet when ripping CD's and communicated directly via WiFi with the Transporter. If I had already ripped all of my CD's, there would be no need for an internet connection.Okay, so what makes The Music Vault a good value? Well, at $1K, you get a music server capable of holding at least 1500 CD's. It does not require a computer, only router to establish a network. CD's are ripped to the hard drive automatically when you insert a CD in the CD drive. The device knows to read the CD, get the CD database information from the web, rip the music to FLAC and archive the data to the internal hard drive. The software on-board is designed to interface seamlessly with Slimserver.How difficult to setup?1) Plug included USB thumb drive with OS into any USB port on the device.2) Plug included ethernet cable from Music Vault into network router.3) Plug in power cord.4) Push the power button.5) You will initially need to establish a work group on the computer network called WORKGROUP. The owners manual gives clear direction for how to do this.6) Open CD tray, insert CD, close the drive and let the Music Vault rip your first CD...repeat, repeat, repeat.Once you have your music loaded on The Music Vault, the Slim Devices product then automatically allows access to all music on the Music Vault via Music Folder.This product is meant to be convenient, efficient and reliable. It is exceptionally well built and the fan is so quiet that I had to put my ear to it to be sure that it was on. The loudest part of the unit is the CD drive while it burns CD's. It is an attractively styled and compact device that simply does what it is supposed to do.Admittedly, those who want to 'roll their own' music server can do so. You will need a computer, hard drive, network connection and one of a variety of programs such as EAC that you will have to manually configure and monitor during the ripping process. You can also use an existing computer with an established network and internal or external hard drives for archiving.The fact is, not everyone has the ability, time or desire to go through all of this. For those who don't, The Music Vault represents, in my opinion, a fantastic value, performance, and ease of use. It is LITERALLY plug and play. It also keeps the music server/computer and music device, such as the Transporter, separate. I believe that the analog music signal should NOT reside inside of a computer. As such, I do not believe that complete music servers - i.e. all in one box, are the best way to go. Computers are inherently electrically noisy inside.Lastly, I would encourage anyone considering putting together a computer-based music server system to consider that for $1K (Music Vault) + $3600 (ModWright modified Transporter) and a $50 router, can put together a $4650 complete computer music server system that will rival CD player and DACs, costing at least 3 x the price. Compare to other 'Music Servers' from other manufacturers at $6K+ - $20K+. And most importantly, you don't have to be a computer whiz to put this together.If you haven't already done so, I would encourage everyone to check out The Music Vault at www.sound sciencecat.com.Take care,Dan WrightPresident, ModWright Instruments Inc.