New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 25303 times.

duggie

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #40 on: 14 Nov 2006, 04:30 pm »
hi tcg,

i know, i am a bit late to this party, but congrats on getting some fine amps, & discovering tubes.  while i discovered them myself a while back, & will not do solid state again, except for subwoofers, i suggest you don't write off stereo amps so quickly.  i have had both monoblocks and stereo amps, (still do, as a matter of fact!), and i can tell you that you *can get the separation you like so much, w/stereo amps.  it's all in the execution.  one of my current fave amps is the diminutive almarro a205a mk-ll, modded w/hovland musicaps.  5wpc, this li'l guy doesn't even have dual input power trannies, but its separation & soundstaging is unreal, w/my 97db/octave speakers.  and, for vintage, check out this recent purchase of mine - i can't wait to try it.  $600 delivered, & it is not only refurb'd, but modded to the gills.  w/its mondo transformers, i am sure separation/soundstaging won't be lacking!  aa

http://cgi.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/cl.pl?ampstube&1167794067


enjoy your tube adventures!   :D

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #41 on: 14 Nov 2006, 04:53 pm »
Hey duggie, thanks!

John / TCG

duggie

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #42 on: 14 Nov 2006, 09:43 pm »
no problem, john; let us know the results of your amp refurb...

Hey duggie, thanks!

John / TCG

jon_010101

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 556
Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #43 on: 14 Nov 2006, 10:13 pm »
i know, i am a bit late to this party, but congrats on getting some fine amps, & discovering tubes.  while i discovered them myself a while back, & will not do solid state again, except for subwoofers, i suggest you don't write off stereo amps so quickly.  i have had both monoblocks and stereo amps, (still do, as a matter of fact!), and i can tell you that you *can get the separation you like so much, w/stereo amps.  it's all in the execution.  one of my current fave amps is the diminutive almarro a205a mk-ll, modded w/hovland musicaps.  5wpc, this li'l guy doesn't even have dual input power trannies, but its separation & soundstaging is unreal, w/my 97db/octave speakers.  and, for vintage, check out this recent purchase of mine - i can't wait to try it.  $600 delivered, & it is not only refurb'd, but modded to the gills.  w/its mondo transformers, i am sure separation/soundstaging won't be lacking!  aa

I have to note: That is one of the best vintage amp restorations I've ever seen!  The choice of parts is perfect; exactly how I'd do a vintage amp if given an big budget.  An insane bargain for that price... a restoration to that degree would cost nearly that much alone -- heck, those Rikens are $3-4 each.   :thumb:

duggie

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #44 on: 14 Nov 2006, 10:38 pm »
i know, i am a bit late to this party, but congrats on getting some fine amps, & discovering tubes.  while i discovered them myself a while back, & will not do solid state again, except for subwoofers, i suggest you don't write off stereo amps so quickly.  i have had both monoblocks and stereo amps, (still do, as a matter of fact!), and i can tell you that you *can get the separation you like so much, w/stereo amps.  it's all in the execution.  one of my current fave amps is the diminutive almarro a205a mk-ll, modded w/hovland musicaps.  5wpc, this li'l guy doesn't even have dual input power trannies, but its separation & soundstaging is unreal, w/my 97db/octave speakers.  and, for vintage, check out this recent purchase of mine - i can't wait to try it.  $600 delivered, & it is not only refurb'd, but modded to the gills.  w/its mondo transformers, i am sure separation/soundstaging won't be lacking!  aa

I have to note: That is one of the best vintage amp restorations I've ever seen!  The choice of parts is perfect; exactly how I'd do a vintage amp if given an big budget.  An insane bargain for that price... a restoration to that degree would cost nearly that much alone -- heck, those Rikens are $3-4 each.   :thumb:

no kidding - that's why i jumped on it!   the jensen pio's are ~$15 a pop, then there's the mills resistors, & the audio note tants, & the black gates & the auricaps...  the an tant resistors make the riken ohms look cheap!  aa and, it didn't hurt that a bud of mine said that a stock never-serviced  sa300 that he had, was one of the best amps he'd ever heard, with *the* best midrange he'd ever heard.  i suspect i may be having to sell one of my other amps after i have listened to this one for a bit.   :D

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #45 on: 12 Dec 2006, 07:30 pm »
Well, theeeeeeey're back today - I pick the Dukies up in a few hours  :thumb:

The Tech said they are wailing away on old Tannoys they use for evaluation....he said they really, really sould great now.

Turns out the reason it went 'pfffft' to begin with was a defective (new) 5U4 rectifier (from Electro-Harmonix).  Kudos to Triode Electronics, tho they are past warranty at 8 months, they are replacing it free of charge (upon return of defective) as I have original box for it (so they can get credited 100% by EH for defect).

So, what has thus far beeen learned from this experience:

1.  If your tube amp doesn't work or makes mum, change out tubes first before thinking it's anything extreme

2.  Keep your old tube boxes around - and spare tubes, too.

Report back when they are set up again  :D

John / TCG




Berndt

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #46 on: 13 Dec 2006, 12:19 am »
We need an update, John!

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #47 on: 13 Dec 2006, 02:29 am »
Warming up now....they sound a lot different than they did before. 

Are the caps and new wiring 'burning in' or is my psyche 'burning in' (okay, let's not go there folks  :nono:)

I'm surprised todays caps are so much physically smaller than the metal-bodied caps of yore.

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #48 on: 14 Dec 2006, 04:34 am »
I really don't want to wade too far into the debate of capacitor and or wire and or resistor break in.....but, this amp has sounded like hell for the past 10 hours of operation.  Really, not pleasant to listen to at all.  Highs are etched, it gets far worse as you juice it any and even the mellowest music is hard to listen to long. Only in the last few hours it's slowly becoming forgiveable sounding - tho I would never buy it outright sounding this way if I heard it for the first time.

I'm gonna' let it cook overnite and see how it fares.  Seriously, all the associated components are the same as are all the tubes in the amps...I have little more to assume than break in for the new parts to blame. 

Oh boy, I'm ducking  :peek:

duggie

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #49 on: 14 Dec 2006, 01:02 pm »
your experience w/break-in is typical.  at the end of the break-in period, i suspect you will no longer have any problems in the future, wading into break-in debates...   :green:


I really don't want to wade too far into the debate of capacitor and or wire and or resistor break in.....but, this amp has sounded like hell for the past 10 hours of operation.  Really, not pleasant to listen to at all.  Highs are etched, it gets far worse as you juice it any and even the mellowest music is hard to listen to long. Only in the last few hours it's slowly becoming forgiveable sounding - tho I would never buy it outright sounding this way if I heard it for the first time.

I'm gonna' let it cook overnite and see how it fares.  Seriously, all the associated components are the same as are all the tubes in the amps...I have little more to assume than break in for the new parts to blame. 

Oh boy, I'm ducking  :peek:

toobluvr

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #50 on: 14 Dec 2006, 04:19 pm »
I really don't want to wade too far into the debate of capacitor and or wire and or resistor break in.....but, this amp has sounded like hell for the past 10 hours of operation.  Really, not pleasant to listen to at all.  Highs are etched, it gets far worse as you juice it any and even the mellowest music is hard to listen to long. Only in the last few hours it's slowly becoming forgiveable sounding - tho I would never buy it outright sounding this way if I heard it for the first time.

I'm gonna' let it cook overnite and see how it fares.  Seriously, all the associated components are the same as are all the tubes in the amps...I have little more to assume than break in for the new parts to blame. 

Oh boy, I'm ducking  :peek:

Hey...
It is what it is...and you hear what you hear...because burn-in is indeed occurring.
It is not some weird brain game, or pseudo-psycho-acoustical effect.

Who cares what the scientists/objectivists say or think?!    :dunno:


TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #51 on: 14 Dec 2006, 09:45 pm »
Yeah guys - it does indeed sound remarkably better today...it's been on for about 30 hours since the cap, wire and resistors were changed out.

It was simply awful/ pathetic yesterday.  It was painfully etched and had what seemed to be very very finite headroom....something that tube amps do have in abundance (gentle breakup when reaching headroom maximum)

We're on our way to tube bliss I hope soon....  :)

Dmason

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1283
Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #52 on: 15 Dec 2006, 12:56 am »
Look at it this way: if it couldn't sound any worse, than you have nothing but its betterment to look forward to. :thumb: I'm not surprised it sounded horrible. I will be surprised if it didn't sound fantastic, in a week or so.

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #53 on: 20 Dec 2006, 06:27 am »
Okay, so there's a good 80-90 hours + on these amps...and I think no further betterment to be had from additional time (at least, I believe so).

One of the EH rectifiers died while at the tech's....so I put the old RCA 5U4's that came with the amps.  For the past few days I've been underwhelmed by my set-up.  I attributed it all to 'burn in' time.

Well, it was partially that....but it was also tired rectifiers. Not patient waiting for the new EH to come back from Triode Electronics in Chicago to match the good one I still have...I decided to buy two new, cryo'ed ones from this guy...

http://cgi.ebay.com/Electro-Harmonix-5U4GB-Cryo-Treated-Rectifier-Tube_W0QQitemZ270013266423QQihZ017QQcategoryZ64629QQtcZphotoQQcmdZViewItem

This guy is $1.50 cheaper per tube than Triode Electronics - and they're cryo'ed, for gosh darn sakes  :)  I don't know how he does it for that price, but they came in here today amazingly well packed.  It took only  :banana piano:a day as he is located only 50 miles south of me.

MINGA!  This amp is now singing.  Perhaps the sole betterment was changing out the tired tubes - or maybe the cryo'ed jobbies mattered - I simply don't care as it's a friggin' lovely listen now.  Damn bit quieter, too, now.

I close my eyes and I'm not noticing any particular tubey signature about these amps - they sound like terrificly refined solid state amps.  I really feel that I gave nothing up in selling off my Odyssey Khartago Mono's - the full frequency extension is there, bass, treble and a bit easier midrange to dial in to and listen.

I'm very taken with these amps today - what a difference a couple new rectifier tubes can do for sonic matters  :thumb:  :banana piano:

JoshK

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #54 on: 20 Dec 2006, 03:07 pm »
My intention is not to start a flame war or a huge tangent, but what is cryo'ing suppose to do for a vacuum tube?  I really don't understand this.   :scratch:   I understand what people think cryo treatment does for metal and the anode and cathode would be the object in question here (maybe even the pins) but when the anode and cathode are heated to really high temperatures (that is how they work) how is this affect suppose to not change.

If cryo'ing is suppose to cause all the metal atomic particles to aline, how is heating the structure so hot that it causes electrons to flow from the cathode to the anode not going to misalign them, once the tube is put to use?  Or is this process suppose to work on something else?

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #55 on: 20 Dec 2006, 04:03 pm »
Josh,

I'm not one to know or say....I have little idea whether the two sets of cryo'ed tubes I've bought in the past were better than their replacements solely because they were newer/fresher - or that there is actual benefit to cryo'ing tubes.

I figure, if I don't pay any more for the process - it probably isn't detrimental to sonics (or my bank statement)  :|

For what it's worth, here is the seller on ebay, SaleRCS, explanation of his Cryoset technique and benefits:

Quote from: SaleRCS
The proprietary Cryoset treatment process utilizes a computer controlled, cryogenic chamber to very gradually reduce the temperature of the tubes to 300 degrees below zero (Farenheit) and holding them there for a minimum of 24 hours. After the extended dwell at this cryogenic temperature, the vacuum tubes are then very slowly brought up to ambient temperature over the next 24 hours and stabilized. The process is a "dry" one that utilizes Liquid Nitrogen as a cryogen that is flashed into the chamber. The tubes are never exposed to the actual liquid. All these processes are microprocessor controlled under strict and verifiable conditions.

Scientists have known for years that material transformations occur when they are exposed to cryogenic temperatures. Many of the early discoveries were more fully explored by NASA engineers who were trying to understand what would happen to metals when subjected to the extreme temperatures of space. Today, a wide range of commercial items - from softball bats to race engines - are cryogenically treated to improve their performance by enhancing the material properties with "cold treating" or cryogenic processing.

This technology brings practical application to audio and other electrical components as well. Cryogenic treatment modifies the microstructure of the metals used in critical electronic components by reducing or eliminating voids and imperfections in the material. Crystal structures (or grains) have been shown to be modified after cryogenic treatment, creating a more uniform or homogenous microstructure. The thermal dissipation properties of the metals is improved, reducing hot spots and further contributing to extended life and improved performance. In addition, the physical contraction of the metals while under the deep freeze imparts a mechanical compression on the metals that contributes to improved signal transmission quality and speed.

The materials used in electronics are highly fabricated and the manufacturing processes used impart or induce stresses in them. In addition, welding and soldering adds additional stress from concentrated areas of heating. Most everyone recognizes that welded components often fail at the weld -- a "weak" spot. The weakness comes from residual stresses inherent in all materials, further exacerbated by manufacturing techniques or processes.

Cryogenic treatment relieves stresses and normalizes (or stabilizes) welded and soldered areas. This mechanism is founded in the observation first made by Bose and later by Einstein, that matter is at it most relaxed state when it has the least amount of kinetic energy (or molecular activity). Absolute zero (-459 Farenheit) is that point where no more energy can be extracted, or when a material is at its most "relaxed" state. While our Cryoset (R) thermal treatment does not get to absolute zero, you can understand how going to minus 300 degrees Fareneheit for an extend dwell time enables the material to become more relaxed and stress relieved.

The transformations that occur as result of cryogenic treatment are a permanent, one time modification to them.

The process makes a permanent change and the benefits do not deteriorate over time or upon return to operating temperature, it changes the whole way the vacuum tube performs. The major benefit has been a dramatic improvement in dymanic range. Bass response has been clearer with reduction in microphonics. The most starling fact has been how the tubes operates under saturated and overdriven conditions. This has made some of the more basic guitar amps sound fuller and warmer.

Listens2tubes

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #56 on: 21 Dec 2006, 02:00 am »
Hi Chairguy, It's been awhile since reading the whole thread so forgive me if this has been addressed but, have you checked/set the bias lately? My Dynaco Mk. IV's sometimes sound thin/hard which indicates too high bias, easily corrected with a screwdriver and digital multi-meter. With all those new components settling-in checking bias fairly often just seems prudent, IMO. Hope I'm not :deadhorse:.

TheChairGuy

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #57 on: 21 Dec 2006, 02:26 am »
Yup, I just paid $450 for servicing of the unit....new caps, resisters, some wiring, biasing and strain relief-ing (no rca's or IEC's on this vintage fella).

Sounds good now with new rectifiers in there....I think my preamp may be the wek-kneed fella in the mix now.

Dmason

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1283
Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #58 on: 21 Dec 2006, 02:41 am »
Just read this; I would indeed re-bias fairly regularly, until evvyting settles down. Should be good to go. And if it never comes around, I would be happy to dispose of the transformers for you, in an ecologically friendly manner. :thumb:

Berndt

Re: New (first) tube amps...and they are doozies
« Reply #59 on: 21 Dec 2006, 02:50 am »
I think my preamp may be the wek-kneed fella in the mix now.

I got one you might like to try...