I just shipped the Yggdrasil back yesterday. As mentioned, it had a mechanical transformer hum that I could hear at my listening position, 12' away. It was loud enough that my wife asked "What is that humming noise?"
The Yggy sounded nice... but so did this other stuff. I just mentioned to someone elsewhere that I would definitely just opt for the Bifrost 2/64 unit. It was dead quiet and sounded great. It had the smoothness but also detail that people have been describing in the Yggdrasil LIM unit. This is actually the second time I've owned the Bifrost 2/64. The first was when I had my Magnepan 3.7i speakers. The speakers were the limiting factor in really being able to appreciate the DAC, and I sold it too quickly.
~Some sort of RME DAC will be staying, whether it's the current one or even the ADI-2/4 Pro SE, which uses the same chip as my Ayre QB-9 Twenty. The features / sound of the RME are incredible, IMO. It's a tremendous product.
~The Ayre QB-9 Twenty will be staying, as it sounds wonderful and is my frame of reference for "right".
~The Modius with AKM4493 will be staying... I paid for it with quarters I found in the couch, and it sounds excellent. I think it is the DAC that Mike Moffat mentioned as a D/S DAC that "sounded waaaaaaaay too good". The Modi Multibit will be staying for similar reasons. I think I bought it with nickels I found in the cupholder of my truck.
There is a reason why Jason Stoddard said he still uses one.
This time around, I will not be quick to sell the Bifrost 2/64. I bought it right and I think this stuff is fun. Besides... Schiit is working on an update for Gungnir that will be D/S. If they come out with some new card for BF 2/64, maybe I'll play with it. I think the Bifrost 2/64 is the best option for me to have one of their DACs that truly does sound great, can be upgraded (when they do it), costs half (or less) of the Yggy, and doesn't have the mechanical hum issues. (Search for that Yggy hum issue, it can be easily fixed, but it's still a thing).
I had similar thoughts as you about buying into the Yggy ecosystem / upgrade path. And then I heard transformer hum, experienced other DACs that sound as good (or better) with far more features never contemplated (and will never be done) by Schiit. And then, you see the pricing for Upgrade cards on Schiit website. $550 for the LIM boards and $850 for the MIB. After what I've experienced with these DACs and as it relates to your question, the Bifrost 2/64, I would absolutely keep the 2/64.
I'll put it to you this way, when I dropped off the Yggdrasil at FedEx yesterday, it was with a sense of relief that "I experienced that and know what that is, and I know what I already have is at least as good, and in very important ways, SUPERIOR".
Hopefully this helps you get past that itch. I know how it is when you're wondering about "that other thing..."
Thanks jmimac351 for you detailed feedback, it was appreciated.
I still pulled the trigger and ordered a Yggy LIM the other week and a new CEC TL5 transport to try out from Japan. I have had the Yggy LIM for about a week now and the TL5 was delivered by FedEx today.
I'm sorry you had a noisy transformer in your Yggy, sounds like you might have gotten a lemon as mine is dead quiet, I have to have my ear up against the chassis to her the tranny inside the yggy, only a slight hum even then. I have been comparing the Bitfrost 2/64 with the Yggy LIM for a week now and can say I love both, but the Yggy is better in my system.
IMO, the sound stage is deeper and taller than the Bitfrost 2/64, but oddly, not wider.... The bass is the first thing I noticed between the two. The bass coming out of the Yggy is significantly better then the BF. This was just what I was looking for as I felt the Bitfrost could be a bit edgy paired to my GR Brutes. They both have the same DAC chip, but different PS and analog circuits and the bass quality and quantity out of the Yggy gives me the perception of reducing the edge I find in the BF when paired with my GR Brutes.
Then today when I hooked up my new CEC TL5 transport to the Yggy and loaded my favorite XRCD, Dire Straits Brothers in Arms. OMG, the Yggy came alive. My system has never sounded this good. I am truly shocked what a change a good transport made.
I have since taken my BF to my office and paired it with my G-Horn amp and Arendal small BS speakers, it ended up being perfect match.

