I tested my Radio Shack meter against a certified calibrated meter and it was within a dB or so, so I'm guessing it was spot on. I'm not sure what explains the difference between what you're reading and what you're hearing. A rock concert is going to be louder than anything you can or should play with most home equipment. It could be as much as 120 dB SPL, the OSHA limit, which will damage your hearing in short order.