I submit... That the average audiophile actually plays only 15 to 20 percent of their music collection.
The reason is they are looking for two things, that magic combination of the sound and (sometimes second) the music that will sound great on their particular system. They may like a certain album but the highs aren't just right, or the bass isn't correct, so it doesn't get played.
I have Arnold Overtures on CD and I listened once or twice, not really a fan of the music. However I heard it on tape at the RMAF and was glued to my chair, could not move through the entire tape.
Back in 1970 or so I had a buddy that had an open reel deck and a Dynaco tube amp with some speakers he made and actually hung from the corners of his room with wires. I still remember that system slamming with Black Sabbath and James Gang, even back then with home made speakers it had a special and different sound.
There are actual master tapes from various sources being sold on Ebay and they are not all that expensive, a few hundred bucks.
I even saw a Black Sabbath master tape a few months ago, Masters of Reality! This adds to the selection, diversity, and possibility of coming across a real gem I say.
I am not going to give up my vinyl any time soon, but I see no reason not to enhance my systems sound with a more exciting (and from what I have heard better sounding) format.