I think it really is a matter of preference. I do actually rip all of my CDs for backup purposes in case I need to reburn if the original gets scratched or damaged (my son snapped one in half once

) but when it comes to relaxing and music listening I guess I'm in that minority who'd rather be nowhere near a computer.
Interesting comments regarding the Oppo as a transport. The anologue-out audio from my Oppo (DV-981HD) is excellent with DVDs, and not too shabby with SACDs, however to my ears the anologue-out CD performance is a long way behind my very old Rotel RCD965BX in terms of scale, dynamics and fluidity (I'm not very good at describing these things). The Rotel's CD performance also beats the Oppo's SACD performance. It could be that the Rotel's internal DAC is that much better than the Oppo's and I wouldn't know this until I compared both the Oppo and Rotel digital outs into a DAC such as the Isabellina. I see there are one or two places that mod the Oppo players' tranports, analogue and digital outputs, but at a cost of course.
After including the $1500 additional outlay for the Isabellina, even with a $100 transport you're then in competion with CD players in the $1600 price category (or a $2500 CD player compared with Isabellina plus buying a $1000 MacBook).
My idea is to get the best transport I can and given I have a number of SACDs also I'm thinking of pulling the trigger on an Esoteric X03-SE, which I can pick up fairly cheaply, and running this anologue into the Isabella. Still, it would be fun to play with the DAC, so I might even get the Isabellina DAC as well as this could handle DVD from the Oppo, given I watch a lot of cinema. The Esoteric has a digital out for Red Book so in that case I could even run that into the Isabellina when playing CDs, should SP/DIF plus Isabellina DAC manage to outperform the Esoteric's own DAC.
Unless Vinnie, you're suggesting the Macbook USD performance is so good it might beat the Esoteric?

In that case I might reconsider things and seriously look at the computer route... I'm looking forward to reading Srajan's conclusions on all this

All the best,
kitten