Help setting up hardware RAID 1

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 3748 times.

lcrim

Help setting up hardware RAID 1
« Reply #20 on: 11 Jan 2006, 02:30 pm »
ctviggen:
You have gotten a lot of good and well-meaning advice from this thread re: backups.  I'm not sure that your desire to back up OS and executables (programs) is a wise choice.  As a rule, my experience has been that you back up only the data necessary and reinstall the OS and programs fresh, to avoid pointless complexity and problems.
In the work environment, we tend to use RAID 1 or disk mirroring for OS's and the main executables (programs) to get fault tolerance not as a backup strategy.  Raid 5 is really best used for larger volumes and to allow for a disk failure w/o losing function, again a fault tolerance solution.
I thought the advice given by Eli made the most sense to me.  Have a smaller disk w/ your OS and programs which you can rebuild completely and from fresh installs.  Keep your ripped music files on a large drive in a USB enclosure and get a second large drive in a USB enclosure to make a second copy of your music and leave that one someplace safe.  This is supposed to be a hobby not a chore.  I always try to make it as simple as possible.

ctviggen

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 5251
Help setting up hardware RAID 1
« Reply #21 on: 11 Jan 2006, 03:10 pm »
Larry,

I'm not sure I agree.  When you lose the OS portion of a drive, you lose a ton of information.  You lose all your settings.  You lose all your updates (and with Microsoft having updates daily not, that's a crap load of updates).  You lose any shareware you mistakenly did not back up or can no longer find the key.  In the past, when I had backups of my OS drive and the drive went down, I simply bought a new drive and restored from (at the time) tape.  That was it.  After my tape drive went down and I didn't have a backup of my OS, I had to reinstall everything, and I had to repurchase some programs I lost.  It can take days to reinstall and get the OS back to where it was before.  Not only that, but to get the data on the data drive, you have to be savvy -- you have to find out where the data is kept (say, for your email programs), and have the program use the data drive.  This is time consuming and confusing, especially after you reinstall and no longer remember how the heck you did that in the first place.  I still like backing up my OS drive and will continue to do so.

Levi

Help setting up hardware RAID 1
« Reply #22 on: 11 Jan 2006, 03:11 pm »
Hi Bob, I would get a backup strategy in place.  Than proceed with your project. :D

Levi

Re: Help setting up hardware RAID 1
« Reply #23 on: 4 Aug 2006, 04:55 pm »
Hey Bob- Any updates on your RAID 1 project?  Did it explode on you or is it a happy ending?