0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 3749 times.
I'm perfectly okay with Pink Floyd in its current incarnation without Roger. I like Momentary Lapse of Reason and the Division Bell just fine. Are they like early PF? Of course not, but the band members aren't 20 any more and I would hope have a slightly different perspective on music and life.My least favorite Pink Floyd album? The Wall. It was okay 35 years ago, but now, I listen to it once every 5-6 years and go "still don't like it".In some ways it is sad that Roger decided to go his own way and then tried to say that he was "Pink Floyd" and without him they couldn't be a band. I'm happy that Mr. Gilmour, Mr. Mason and Mr. Wright soldiered on without him. I'll pick up a copy as soon as it is released and give it a listen.HsvHeelFan
Bad news, not what I was expecting.
Bah. IMO, Gilmour (along with Wright) brought the majority of the musicality to PF. I know plenty love Waters' solo work, but if you objectively listen to that compared to Gilmour's solo albums, you can clearly hear where the Pink Floyd sound/mood/melodies came from.From my understanding of the new album, it has a basis from the leftovers of the Division Bell, but also incorporates Wright's recent work. I know he was working on a solo album before he passed, but I don't know if any of that will be/was directly related to the leftovers. Moreover, Gilmour and Mason have been adding to (at least) the leftovers.WAIVER: I am a huge PF fan who also thinks the Division Bell is absolutely amazing. I personally can't wait for this new album and its announcement put a grin on my face for about a week. Paul