Christgau's Consumer Guide-Ending after 40 years?

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 1216 times.

Lyndon

Christgau's Consumer Guide-Ending after 40 years?
« on: 6 Aug 2010, 09:26 pm »
I've not always agreed with Robert Christgau's music critic column, but he wasn't wishy washy about what he liked and didn't like.  He was a mainstay at the Village Voice, and started their Pazz & Jop Review.
He was fired from the Voice, and maintained his monthly column online at MSN. Now that has ended as well.  I still like Lester Bangs as my top music critic of the 60's and 70's, but Christgau turned me on to a lot of music that I wouldn't have tried without his suggestions.
Last Consumer Guide:
http://music.msn.com/music/consumerguide/
Commentary:
http://tinyurl.com/2c2pvv5
http://tinyurl.com/2upuvd9
It was irritating that a lot of his world music recommendations were either not obtainable, or priced quite high.  Of course, he had received his copy 'au gratis'.
I wonder who takes over as the most read music critic of pop/current music these days?
Jon Pareles of the NY Times?
http://rockcriticsarchives.com/interviews/jonpareles/jonpareles.html

WolfsongAudio

Constuct
« Reply #1 on: 16 Sep 2010, 09:16 pm »
Here Here on the Meadowlark Audio Comment.  Pat is a great engineer and an even better guy.  I have owned just about all of his commercial designs and for my tastes, they are unsurpassed.  His company's demise had a lot to do with the transition from MDF to hardwood baffles and tops as well as the fully custom order capability he allowed customers and dealers.  When you give the average consumer the option to choose the wood species and the stringers on the baffle, they can get really creative .................and then when they get exactly what they described, they are reluctant to accept the fact that wood is a natural product and will have inherent variations.  I worked for 10 years at one of the first dealers in the country to handle Meadowlarks and we had no less than 5 pairs of custom order speakers turned back by customers who could not understand things like "Ambrosia beetles caused the amazing color variations in this maple" to mean bugs had made holes in the wood.  Or things like " this ropey cherry has amazing fire and texture" to mean it ain't flat like formica! 
    Yet other companies can continue to produce speakers that measure poorly, sound awful and look like Salvador Dali and Walt Disney had a kid and they soldier on for decades.
     Reviewers are like any other machine.  They are either a benefit or a hazard.  If they are a benefit, they are not my problem.

Lyndon

Re: Christgau's Consumer Guide-Ending after 40 years?
« Reply #2 on: 16 Sep 2010, 10:23 pm »
WolfsongAudio
I think you may have posted on the wrong thread, but I'm grateful ANYBODY responded to my post on Christgau.  Man, I miss his pithy
comments on new music.
The only way I get some written comments and criticism these days is through Paste magazine online (their hard copy just died), and NPR Listen Now blogs and reports.
 :cry:

WolfsongAudio

Re: Christgau's Consumer Guide-Ending after 40 years?
« Reply #3 on: 17 Sep 2010, 12:28 am »
Lyndon,
 

    Sorry, I thought this was attached to a broader thread about reviews and reviewers that were very off target so as to be less than useless.  Did not mean to hijack the thread.