I had the same problem last night. Nothing new to watch.... so I popped in My Cousin Vinny and laughed. The expressions and voice inflection from Mona Lisa Vito (Marissa Tomei) are incredible! I find myself trying to bob my head the way she does, just to see if I can do it.
Very, very funny movie. It helps that I'm in Alabama these days also.
Make yourself a list of your most rewatchable films, and then go to that short list when you can't decide what you're in the mood for. The short list helps in the face of overwhelming choices. My short list includes:
Office Space
My Cousin Vinny
5th Element
Matrix
Spiderman
The One
Terminator 3
The Scorpion King (yes, I must admit I like this popcorn flick)
Most of the Star Trek films
Dumb and Dumber
I don't own Super Troopers yet, but this has made my list
and a bunch of others...
My list is mostly comedies, I guess, with a few popcorn flicks thrown in.
John G