Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 4402 times.

Tony1

Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« on: 13 Aug 2009, 03:31 am »
Two Beatles box set are going to be released next month one in mono and the other in stereo.  In reading the description of the mono set it says that no compression was used so I assume this is good and would sound good on a two channel system.  But wonder if the stereo would sound better even though there may be some compression.  I am wondering which version to get. Any opinions on mono vs stereo on a 2 channel system?

JerryM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 4711
  • Where's The Bar?
Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #1 on: 13 Aug 2009, 03:47 am »
One of each, then decide yourself.  :thumb:

Have fun,
Jerry

richidoo

Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #2 on: 13 Aug 2009, 06:28 am »
Get the stereo version. What the heck - you only live once! They were all recorded to 4 tracks through Sgt peppers then more channels after that, but all were intended to be mixed to stereo. Both are legit mixes, but the monos haven't been available new for a long time.  In the 60s both formats were sold side by side, but most listened to mono radios and record players so some might like those for nostalgia. They are different mixes, not just a summing of stereo to mono which ruins the music.

Compression is not good or bad. There is so much compression in the original George Martin mixes that no more is needed in the remasters. They know the mix is part of the art so they can't touch it.

markmaloof

Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #3 on: 13 Aug 2009, 06:51 am »
If you want to be a "purist" and go with what the Beatles intended, you go mono.  Up to and including the White Album, the Beatles and George Martin (along with the engineer of course) would mix exclusively in mono.  Stereo was new at the time and considered a gimmick, so serious time would be spent with the mono mixes, and the engineer (Geoff Emerick, Norman Smith) would have to task to put together a stereo mix in a couple days (though Emerick sure did a nice job with Pepper even though the stereo was just "tossed off".)  I have both UK/Japanese mono and stereo pressings, and like both for differing reasons (yeah, not what you want to hear, I would say get BOTH.)  Certain albums (mostly later ones) have very notable mix differences between the monos and stereos (and if you are a geek like me, you will want to hear both.)  The best (besides if these see the light of day as vinyl, though don't know if they will top my UK Blue Box stereos and Japanese red monos) would be if they eventually sold the albums separately in mono and stereo.  Then I would say get Pepper, The While Album Revolver and Rubber Soul in Mono.

Some differences: very different sounding "Tomorrow Never Knows" on Revolver.  Srgt. Pepper sounds very different in mono, guitars are mixed louder on some songs, different sound effect levels, other things (John Lennon went on record as claiming mono Pepper to be the only version people should hear if they wanted what the Beatles intended.)

The biggest differences of all are apparent in the White album, and sometimes the mono mix is THE one for me (and sometimes it's the stereo mix.)  Some songs sound quite different: Blackbird and Piggies have different animal sounds, Don't Pass Me By is at a different speed!  But Helter Skelter....the mono mix is punk rock.  Paul's voice is mixed dry and forward, the guitars are more raw sounding and in your face, and weird sound effects pop in and out more notably.  Also, no false return ending and "I've got blisters on my fingers."

konut

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 1581
  • Came for the value, stayed for the drama
Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #4 on: 13 Aug 2009, 12:06 pm »
Excellent info markmaloof! :thumb: Put me down for the stereo set as that's the way I heard them originally. Only wish I could get the set as the American releases. 

Phil A

Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #5 on: 13 Aug 2009, 12:32 pm »
I preordered the mono as it is a ltd. edition.  I'll probably get the stereo one too.

nrenter

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 409
Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #6 on: 13 Aug 2009, 01:14 pm »
I have both sets on pre-order.  :D

woodsyi

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 6513
  • Always Look on the Bright Side of Life!
Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #7 on: 13 Aug 2009, 01:21 pm »
I have neither set on order.  :lol:

I am waiting for them to put the sets on vinyl.   :P

woodsyi

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 6513
  • Always Look on the Bright Side of Life!
Re: Which Beatles box set: Mono or Stereo
« Reply #8 on: 13 Aug 2009, 01:21 pm »
dup. :oops: