The thing with personal taste is...It's personal!!
I have had both the CineMags and the Piccolo, back to back, in the same listening session, in my system.
I preferred the CineMags (wired at 1:36) by a wide margin, but...My cartridge is a Sound-Smith re-tipped DL-103!
I am not saying that the Piccolo is not a fine piece of equipment at all, it just wasn't my cup of tea in my system, with my other components (VPI HW-19 MkIII/SME 309, Clarinet line stage, Cornet2 phono, Heathkit W5-M amps and Altec 846A speakers).
The Piccolo is super flexible and priced right, that's for sure. I do wish I would have tried it with my Ortofon MC20 Super as I have not found a transformer that sounds right with that particular cartridge (it originally came packaged with the Ortofon MCA-76 headamp).
The CineMags are far less flexible and aside from the aforementioned Denon, I have only heard a Benz ACE and my Ortofon MC20 though them.
Drop me a line if you would like to rid yourself of those CineMags as I wouldn't mind another set of trannies for my living room rig. (anumber1 at charter dot net)