Very informative review

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 1751 times.

lcrim

Very informative review
« on: 3 Sep 2007, 03:25 pm »
http://www.dagogo.com/DIYHeartland/AqvoxPhono2CI.html
The reply from the firm's technical guy of the phonostage being reviewed is what caught my eye.  In pointing out the advantages of his product, which has a balanced output, he states:
Just remember:

MC-cartridges are balanced current generators

MM-cartridges are voltage generators

I've read this a few times and while I'm sure it has great pertinence I don't fully grasp it.  I know that Nelson Pass's new First Watt F4 amplifier uses a similar principle but perhaps someone can better explain this.

Steve Eddy

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 877
    • http://www.q-audio.com
Re: Very informative review
« Reply #1 on: 3 Sep 2007, 04:24 pm »

Basically, a current source is characterized by a high (ideally infinite) output impedance which delivers a constant current regardless of load impedance. A voltage source is characterized by a low (ideally zero) output impedance which delivers a constant voltage regardless of load impedance.

The voltage across a current source's output is determined by the load impedance as per Ohm's Law, E = I x R. The current through a voltage source's output is determined by the load impedance as per Ohm's Law, I = E/R.

A current source prefers to see a low (ideally zero) load impedance while a voltage source prefers to see a high (ideally infinite) load impedance.

So as you can see, current sources and voltage sources are essentially the inverse of each other.

Some feel that the output of an MC cartridge is best characterized as a current source. So to that end, it is argued that an MC cartridge should ideally drive a short circuit.

While the manufacturer's comment refers to the MC inputs of the AQVOX as a "current amplifier," others (especially those who have played around with DACs) may be more familiar with the term current-to-voltage or I/V converter.

If you take an opamp, and configure it as an inverting amplifier, its "-" input acts as a virtual ground, i.e. a short circuit which is what the current source wants to see, and the opamp outputs a voltage that's proportional to the current flowing through its "-" input.

That's essentially what's being done here. The 47 Labs Phono Cube also uses this method. And there are those who feel that the primary job of an MC step-up transformer isn't so much to provide signal amplification as it is to present the MC cartridge with a much lower load impedance and act in a sense as a passive current-to-voltage converter.

This help?

se


lcrim

Re: Very informative review
« Reply #2 on: 3 Sep 2007, 05:18 pm »
Thanks, yes it does help. 
It seems that the output from the MC must be balanced for the circuit to work optimally.  All the connections in my systems are single ended and to take advantage of this method, it apparently would necessitate changing to all balanced components which would be a huge stumbling block. 

Steve Eddy

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 877
    • http://www.q-audio.com
Re: Very informative review
« Reply #3 on: 3 Sep 2007, 05:49 pm »
It seems that the output from the MC must be balanced for the circuit to work optimally.  All the connections in my systems are single ended and to take advantage of this method, it apparently would necessitate changing to all balanced components which would be a huge stumbling block.

As far as the interface between the cartridge and the input of the AQVOX is concerned (which is where the I/V conversion is taking place), it's just a matter of cabling. The outputs of the AQVOX are conventional voltage source outputs. So all you'd need is a balanced cable running from your turntable to the AQVOX inputs. Even if you use the AQVOX's unbalanced outputs, you still retain the benefits of its balanced input.

se


lcrim

Re: Very informative review
« Reply #4 on: 3 Sep 2007, 06:20 pm »
I actually had my Technics 1200 tonearm rewired w/ Cardas Litz by KAB and it would be a simple matter to change to a 5 pin DIN connector and get the manufactured wire loom that has a male DIN on one end and XLR connectors at the other.

Steve Eddy

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 877
    • http://www.q-audio.com
Re: Very informative review
« Reply #5 on: 3 Sep 2007, 07:19 pm »
I actually had my Technics 1200 tonearm rewired w/ Cardas Litz by KAB and it would be a simple matter to change to a 5 pin DIN connector and get the manufactured wire loom that has a male DIN on one end and XLR connectors at the other.

That would do it.

Good luck!

se


TONEPUB

Re: Very informative review
« Reply #6 on: 3 Sep 2007, 09:10 pm »
We are also finishing up a review on the Aqvox...

It is surprisingly good for a low price and if you can use the balanced inputs
even a bit better!

Great phono preamp for the money!