Like someone else said how "old" is it? Mine got progressivly warmer as the caps broke in. What caps are you running?
I wonder if ANY 5AR4 (even cheap Sovtek or JJ) might not give you a more lush sound than a 5Y3
You've already got the Mullard rec so I won't repeat it, but I'll toss out that I found more difference between long and short plate mullards than I did between short plate Mullards and new production tubes. So watch which you get if you are looking for the richness. I liked the Amperex short plates better than the Mullard short plates, but the long plates are a whole other animal.
Depending on HOW much richness you want you might take a look at RCA black plates. I thought they traded too much detail, but YMMV.