I had fun with the movie, but I could not get past the notion that Johnny Depp was doing a Keith Richards impersonation the whole time. Doesn't make him a bad guy (Depp was one of my picks for best actors of our generation), but it definitely seemed to be influenced by Keith.
Also, that pirate with the glass eye.... tell me that he wasn't imitating "Dim" from A Clockwork Orange.
A fun movie - but I was distracted by these similarities. Once something like that gets in your head it's hard to shake it off.