lcrim,
why should new LP's be cheaper than CD's (i.e. $10)??? Granted, there ARE some around $10 (Ryan Adams on Lost Highway, Original Jazz Classics) but I think they're the exceptions. Especially when one considers how much longer CD's are time-wise, causing the vinyl equivalent to be TWO LP's to contain the same tracks. Two recent vinyl additions were Johnny Cash and Lucinda Williams (both on Lost Highway) that were 2 LP sets for $16 or 18??? No complaints from me on those prices.
Why don't you try some of the "Bestsellers" on LP Now??? These are older titles, but still sealed, some of which are quite reasonable (like the early Lucinda Williams). They have a flat $6 s/h so it kinda benefits you to order several titles to spread out the shipping fee. They also have some coupons if you get over $30.