Hi Six,
JLM has a point in regard to deciding which "type" of sound you prefer and should be based on something you can live with for a long time. The perfect amp for every application does not exist and everyone will have a different opinion when recommending one to you. You and your ears are the only judge.
. Tubes tend to sound warm, euphoric, and/or seductive. They clip kindly or gracefully. They tend not to have bass authority. Simpler the better SETs have more detail and speed, but available power is very low.
Yes, I am becoming a bit biased here as tubes are the only thing I can and will listen to. Not to say anything negative about solid state rather my personal preference. This is not to say that tubes would be the best choice for you. To drive some of the speakers you mentioned such as the Maggies, most tube amps would work but to get full potential and authority, you would need a higher powered unit that could be costly.
Solid state are less romantic sounding. They clip hard and ugly. They sound best near their rated output, typically are more powerful than tubes, have speed, and bass authority.
Agreed. Solid state would give you more authority and control. There are some very nice (warmer) sounding SS pieces out there and auditioning would be in order to choose the right one for you. I do not beleive in the old school thought of "an amp is an amp and they all sound the same". This is simply not true. For those who beleive in this, their life is much easier as they need not spend much money at Circuit City to get a system up and running.
Digital is early on the learning curve, but very promising. RF noise, need for clean power, and distortion quirks are still being researched. But they have the warmth of tubes with the speed and power of solid state. And they hold the promise in CD/SACD/DVD systems of eliminating analog conversion of the signal altogether
In all honesty, I do not have a lot of experience with Digital. What I have heard did impress me to the point of wanting to experiment more but still not the tube sound I find hard to get away from.
IMO this is a crummy time to buy an amp. I'd wait to see what comes from the digital "revolution". I forsee solid state going away and two major camps developing. The vintage camp (tubes, vinyl, and higher efficiency speakers) and the digital camp (audio PCs using built in digital amp boards and playback via hard drives from compressed, lossless files downloaded from the web).
This is the only statement I am not sure I agree with. While digital may become more popular, I do not see solid state going to the curb any time soon. Many made the same statement in regard to CD vs SACD. It may someday happen but not an overnight happening. Solid state, as well as CD will be here for MANY years.
JLM, I am not saying you are wrong but do have a different opinion. It will obviously be interesting to see what develops in the world of audio. I can only predict [my] future and tubes will be in it.
SIX - no one can tell what what is best for you and your ears. Audio is a pasion and hobby with no limitations. If there were one best products and technology, there would be only one audio company selling. Options are everywhere. The world of the internet has a twofold effect on the hobby; ie, it opens a world of options to choose from but at the same time makes it much more difficult as you cannot always audition those options. No matter what you decide upon, you will always wonder.......what if??