Would you be interested in an older (maybe 13-ish years) Forte Model 40? Forte was the budget line that Threshold came out with.
It has a phono input that I use for MM - Can't say how flexible for MC, I just don't recall. Separate power supply.
It has 6 inputs, including the phono.
Unit works well, I'm in the process of replacing it.
Don't have a price in mind but I think it'll be less than half of your lower range.
If you want more info, PM me and I can check current Orion blue-book price. I think it was around $1100 new, but that was a while ago! (original owner/no original box or manual)
I barely want to sell it at its current value, but since you asked maybe its written in the stars that this should be.