Best Sounding Computer Transport: PC, Mac MINI, or Linux?

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 1317 times.

davehg

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 97
    • http://musicserver.blogspot.com
Ok, bought the Squeezebox 3, will likely do the Bolder mods and upgrade the PS.  I will be using the SB3 with a Tri-Vista DAC (yeah, I have heard all about USB DACS...I am using what I have).

Since I am starting ground up, I have ultimate flexibility on which PC and software to use with the Squeezebox.  I will dedicate this PC to music only, nothing else. All of the solutions below will be linked to external USB or FireWire drives. I really want the best combination of ease of use plus sound quality. Feedback?

Apple MAC Mini.
PRO: Complete, compact, reasonably quiet, good value, very user friendly, can use Itunes playing .WAV or AIFF files, easy to burn to external drives.
CON: Accessories add to price, people claim Foobar playing .WAC or FLAC is better, can't use EAC to rip. Can't use my IPAQ as a remote. A bit of a pain to integrate with my current XP computers.

Windows XP on a fanless or quiet Mini-Itx System
PRO: I already have an XP system to network to, the opposite of the Apple CON's.  Plus, I have a Wifi IPAQ I could use as a remote control, plus I can use Foobar and FLAC or WAV files and EAC.
CON: Have to find and assemble (or have vendor assemble) the necessary hardware. Gordon Ranking claims PC's are inferior. XP is a huge OS, so I need a hard drive. Probably more than a MAC MINI

Damn Small Linux on a fanless Mini-Itx, booting off CF card.
PRO: No hard drive, small and very dedicated, can use FLAC files.
CON: Not user or newbie friendly, still have to figure out how to burn to the external hard drives. Can't use my IPAQ

I am leaning toward the MAC MINI, primarily due to convenience. Thoughts? Anyone actually do their own A/B comparisons?

Brad

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 2172
Best Sounding Computer Transport: PC, Mac MINI, or Linux?
« Reply #1 on: 2 Nov 2005, 09:40 pm »
With the Mac Mini, go with Apple Lossless format.
If you're using Slimserver, you can use your IPAQ as a remote - the mini just becomes a webserver that you can connect to with the IPAQ.

It does play pretty well with XP too.