Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 11511 times.

zybar

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 12071
  • Dutch and Dutch 8C's…yes they are that good!
Salk Sound Veracity HT3 Review

The HT3’s are a 3-way floor standing speakers of medium height (about 44” tall with the supplied spikes) that are darn heavy (somewhere around 130lbs each).  The drivers used are all well known and acknowledged as some of the better ones out there:

•   Tweeter – G2 ribbon tweeter
•   Mid-range – SEAS W18EX 8” mid-range
•   Woofer – TC Sounds 989 10” woofer

Add to these a Dennis Murphy designed crossover with premium parts and you start to see why Jim has something very special here…

With a build quality that my limited vocabulary can’t do justice to; suffice it say that you won’t have any WAF issues with these speakers.  In fact, the HT3’s just might be the nicest piece of furniture in many of the rooms they will call home!  You can see pictures of various HT3’s here on AudioCircle or over at Jim’s website:  www.salksound.com.  For now, here is a picture of mine:



Enough on the looks, how do they sound?  

In one word – “Engaging”

When I sit down and put a cd in, I no longer want to have my laptop next to me or worse, on my lap doing work or surfing the net .  Instead, I want to sit in my chair, close my eyes, and sink into the music (I happen to be breaking this right now at the request of Chris – how can I not fulfill his request?) .  From the first note to the last note of the session, the music demands my full attention and rewards me with a system that is capable of knocking you back in the chair with its impact and dynamics, while getting the decay on a bell just right, and still properly capturing the texture and sexiness of a female voice.  But I am getting ahead of myself…you can hear about how all the pieces produce the final results with my comments below on some of my standard reference cd’s and tracks.

I would say that overall sound of the HT3’s is very well balanced top to bottom with great range (the measured bass response in my room via the TacT is pretty much flat at 30Hz and down 4.4 db’s at 22Hz – the midrange is pretty much flat - on the top end the measured response is excellent up to 20,000Hz where the TacT stops measuring).  The midrange is incredibly clean, detailed, and fast, while being smooth and without an artificial or etched sound.  These speakers allow you to have your cake and eat it to in terms of detail and musical enjoyment!  

Because of these factors (plus the very good component matching) – see my equipment list below), I am able to get a more complete representation of the cd than I could in my previous systems.  I would say it is equivalent of going from a very good DVD on very good jpg to an HD source on the same jpg.  The extra detail adds to the realism of the moment and is a big part of seducing the listener and making them want to sit there and listen for hour after hour, cd after cd.  The nuances and texture of the music are easily there and don’t require you to concentrate on the music to pick them up.  Instead, it is all laid out in front of you.  These are the first speakers I have had in a long time where listening to music wasn’t work, but something that was relaxing.  

I have found that the soundstage varies from recording to recording and can be deep when the music was recorded in such a manner.  More importantly, the speakers do disappear and don’t draw attention to themselves.  If I didn’t know where they were located, it would be impossible to pinpoint where they are located.

To finish off the review, I thought it would be useful to describe what I heard on a few of my reference or test cuts.  Some people are probably familiar with a few of them (especially the NY Audio Rave folks) and I think it adds a little context to the review.  I used songs that I am extremely familiar with and that also test the system in different ways.

Natalie Merchant – Tigerliliy (female vocals, percussion, piano, acoustic guitar, soundstage)

Track 5 – Carnival

•   The opening drums, bongos, and bass are very well defined in their individual spaces.  There is good layering front to back.
•   The dynamics are crisp and lightning fast.  The bongos have a depth and realism to them that I don’t get from most systems.

Track 7 – The Letter
•   The piano has the proper weight and body – notes are substantial and give the proper illusion of size that a piano should have.
•   The emotion of Natalie’s voice is so right it is spooky.  Her voice can be a sexy or husky at times and the HT3’s nail it!

The Bad Plus – These Are the Vistas (bass, piano, drums)

Track 2 – Keep the Bugs Off Your Glass and the Bears Off Your Ass
•   Really shows off the dynamic range of the system.
•   The finger work on the bass is tremendous and the notes go deep while staying fast and not blurring or mushing together.
•   The cymbals are light and airy – they float away instead of dieing a quick death.
•   Just like with Natalie, the piano is very full and organic – no toy piano here!
•   In the middle of the track, things get busy and the speakers handled this very well.  All instruments are still very detailed, musical, and defined.  The music doesn’t become incoherent or scrambled.

Sam Cooke – Night Beat (male vocal, bass, cymbals)

Track 2 – Lost and Lookin’
•   Sam’s voice has the right timbre and weight to it.
•   This is a simple track that highlights Sam’s incredible voice and the bass and cymbals are very deep in the soundstage and are totally dominated by the vocal.
•   I just dim the lights on this one and I can picture Sam in the studio singing…

Ben Harper – Fight For Your Mind (male vocals, slide and acoustic guitar, percussion, bass)

Track 5 – Gold to Me
•   Cymbals have some great shimmer and decay.
•   Bass line is tight and tuneful throughout the song.
•   The bells and smaller percussion instruments are easy to identify and don’t get overpowered.

Track 13 – God Fearing Man
•   Wicked guitar play is captured in all its glory!
•   Ben’s voice is full of soul and the music really grabbed me.
•   Percussion goes deep and lays a very solid foundation for his voice and guitar.

All of my listening is done in my dedicated room that is 25x18x7 and is treated with acoustical products from RealTraps and EigthNerve, as well as acoustic foam from Foam By Mail.

My associated equipment consists of the following:



•   TacT RCS 2.2x preamp/dac/room correction w/ SupraSowrd LoRad power cord
•   McCormack DNA-500 amp w/ VH Audio AirSine power cord
•   Empirical Audio modified Sony S-7700 dvd player as a transport
•   Running Springs Audio Haley on its own dedicated 20 amp line (TacT and Sony are plugged into it)
•   Running Springs Audio Duke on its own dedicated 20 amp line (DNA-500 is plugged into it)
•   Sistrum SP-101 platform under DNA-500
•   Sistrum SP-1 platform under TacT and Sony
•   Sistrum SP-004 platform under RSA Duke and Haley
•   VH Audio cryo’d Pulsar with Silver NextGen connectors for digital ic
•   VH Audio Balanced Pulsars with Furutech Rhodium connectors for analog ic’s
•   TG Audio HSR speaker cable
•   Argent Audio Pursang jumpers

I could go on and on, but I think you get the point – I REALLY like these speakers!!  :thumb:

The review wouldn't be complete if I didn't say what a pleasure it has been to interact with Jim Salk.  He answers questions quickly and is willing to work with you to customize the speakers in terms of looks and internal parts.  He will be totally honest with you and not try to sell you anything you don’t need or want.

Lastly, if you are in the market for a pair of speakers, I highly recommend you figure out a way to listen to a pair of HT3’s before buying anything else.  They aren’t perfect (I am sure I will eventually find some flaws – other than the fact that they take a long time to be made) and everybody won't love them like I do, but man oh man, unless I spent $17K on the Vandy 5’s, I haven’t heard a speaker that I have liked more than the Veracity HT3’s.

CornellAlum

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 493
Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #1 on: 11 Jul 2005, 02:06 am »
Could you possibly say more about what your old speakers didn't do that the new ones do :?:   I am curious, and well, curiosity killed the...


D-------

denf

Veracity HT3
« Reply #2 on: 11 Jul 2005, 02:09 am »
Great review! I have come a knat's hair away from buying the Veracity's but haven't been able to find anyone close enough that owns a pair where I might get a quick audition.

Was wondering what other speakers you have owned, and more specifically what the HT-3's recently replaced, so we all have a better frame of reference?

Thanks again for taking the time to "pen" a great review.

Dennis (NOT of the hurricane type)

NealH

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 373
Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #3 on: 11 Jul 2005, 02:34 am »
Very nice review.  And your room set-up looks like a work of art.  And the speakers - well they are just excellent looking.  

I listened to a pair of Selah RC4's this weekend at Rick Craig's house and, they appear to have similar drivers (midrange and treble anyway) to these  Salk HT3 speakers.  The resolution and realism are probably the best I've heard from a cone speaker.  The Soundlab Ultimates that I listen to have virtually the same clarity, purity and realism - just a larger and more volumetric image/scale.  

In my opinion speakers like these Salks and the Selah RC4 were conceived with a receipe for success by starting off with top notch drivers.   It's good news that it doesn't take high dollar electrostatic speakers to obtain this  sonic realism today.

lonewolfny42

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 16918
  • Speakers....What Speakers ?
Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #4 on: 11 Jul 2005, 02:53 am »
Thank you George....you type fast... :lol:
    Nice review, much better than I could write... :thumb: [/list:u]
      Here's a little story...Back on saturday, Feb. 26th, 2005 , George had a little get-together at his place. Had just received an audition pair of the  HT3's, and he wanted to get some opinions. George, Bob, Ken, and Jim and myself. You can read all about it
here....[/list:u]
    Its was a fun day comparing speakers and listening to George's equipement.[/list:u]
      But I have one thing that I always remember about that day....since I'm usually the last to leave, George and I did a little "magic hour", playing cd after cd, cut after cut. And the HT3's sounded so sweet !!! And, the last cut of the night...SVR...Tin Pan Alley...can't get over how great it sounded....like he as there in front of us. The thought is etched in my brain.... :lol: - thats how good it sounded. Truth be told...I hated to leave, but it was late....and a long day.[/list:u]
        Enjoy those speakers George  :hyper: ...hopefully your search is over...and you have been thru alot of speakers. And pretty soon it seems, you'll have a lot more company speaking their praises as their HT3's get built. I'm glad I got to hear them...thanks !!![/list:u]
          Chris[/list:u]

ekovalsky

Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #5 on: 11 Jul 2005, 03:19 am »
Great review George, much better than most of the dribble on I read on 6moons, Stereotimes and the printed rags that take weeks to write.  And since you didn't get the speakers for free or at cost and are not planning to resell them for profit, what you say is actually believable!

It's been fun watching your system evolve over the past few years.  Obviously it sounds and looks better than ever.  The HT3 must be the perfect loudspeaker for the married or engaged man :)

From my previous correspondence with Jim, it was obvious he has great passion about his work.  His recipe for success is pretty simple -- top quality drivers, expertly designed crossovers, and furniture quality cabinetry with strict quality control.  

Considering the HT3 is equipped with a single 10" woofer the in-room bass extension is most impressive.   When I was contemplating having Jim and Christof build me a high end, 2pc per side array system (which still may happen one day!) the 12" version of that driver is what I would have chosen.  The TC2+ models very well for both ported and sealed designs, and it is reasonably priced.  

It sounds like you've been able to reach a state of synaesthesia with your current setup.  Congratulations and ENJOY  :!:

Captain Humble

Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #6 on: 11 Jul 2005, 03:35 am »
Zybar,
Great job on the review.
As my Cajun friends would say, those babies are serious pretty. :inlove:

Enjoy the music.
Jeff

zybar

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 12071
  • Dutch and Dutch 8C's…yes they are that good!
Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #7 on: 11 Jul 2005, 02:17 pm »
Quote from: CornellAlum
Could you possibly say more about what your old speakers didn't do that the new ones do :?:   I am curious, and well, curiosity killed the...


D-------


You can read what people think about the differences between the HT3's and RM 40's in this thread:

http://www.audiocircle.com/index.php?topic=17129&start=0

Regards,

George

zybar

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 12071
  • Dutch and Dutch 8C's…yes they are that good!
Re: Veracity HT3
« Reply #8 on: 11 Jul 2005, 02:33 pm »
Quote from: denf
Great review! I have come a knat's hair away from buying the Veracity's but haven't been able to find anyone close enough that owns a pair where I might get a quick audition.

Was wondering what other speakers you have owned, and more specifically what the HT-3's recently replaced, so we all have a better frame of reference?

Thanks again for taking the time to "pen" a great review.

Dennis (NOT of the hurricane type)


The HT3's are replacing my VMPS MLS African Ebony RM 40's (they are for sale here and on Audiogon).

I have owned the following speakers (in no particular order):

Linn - Tukans, Keilidhs
Maggie - 2.7
Coincident - Conquest, Triumph, Super Conquest
Gallo - References
Silverline Sonata II's
VMPS RM 40's
JM Reynaud Twins Mk II

I have spent significant time either in my house or at a friend's system with the following speakers:

Coincident - Super Eclipse
Merlin - VSM
Silverline - Sonatina II
Reference 3A - MM DeCapo
Vandersteen - 3A Sigs, 5's, 5A's
Meadowlark - Kestrel 2's
Maggie - 1.6's, 3.6's
B&W - Nautilus 803, 802
SP Tech - Continuums
Audio Physic - Virgo I and II
Verity Audio - Parsifal
Martin Logan - Aerius i

Plus many, many more that I just can't think of right now.

George

Hantra

Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #9 on: 12 Jul 2005, 03:25 am »
Fine review sir.

What do those babies retail for?

Thanks,

B

zybar

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 12071
  • Dutch and Dutch 8C's…yes they are that good!
Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #10 on: 12 Jul 2005, 03:26 am »
Quote from: Hantra
Fine review sir.

What do those babies retail for?

Thanks,

B


I think they are now $4400 with upgraded finish.

George

Gordy

Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #11 on: 12 Jul 2005, 03:48 am »
Excellent George, thank you!  

"When I sit down and put a cd in, I no longer want to have my laptop next to me or worse, on my lap doing work or surfing the net . Instead, I want to sit in my chair, close my eyes, and sink into the music."

Pretty much says it all... 8)

PeteG

Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #12 on: 12 Jul 2005, 10:54 am »
That’s a very good price for what you get, great looking speakers
George.

I hope I can hear them at RMAF.

Pete

ericstev

  • Newbie
  • Posts: 2
Salk Sound Veracity HT3's (very long review with a few pics)
« Reply #13 on: 12 Sep 2005, 02:06 am »
zybar


What was your take on the Vandersteen 5a? I have heard so many good things about them. How would they stack up to your new speakers?

Thanks