I'd prefer a combo amp, but could go w/ a half stack. I want something low powered. The ideal amp to copy would be a Vox AC30 or maybe one of the Fenders like the Delexe Reverb.
Hi Doc,
Good to see you around again. Your question is difficult because the AC30 and the Vintage Fenders are two different sounds. The AC30 is class A and the Fender is A/B, the old vintage Fender at least. I like both but if I had to pick one, I'd go for the Fender. Unlike audiophile amps, I love low powered tube designs for guitars because they sound cool when you overdrive them. High powered designs sound cool also but your ears and your neighbors take a beating because they have to be turned up too loud to distort.
I would try to find a copy of an old Fender design. There is a company in Naperville, my town!, that makes exact replicas of older Fender tweed amps. The company is the Victory Amplifier Company. You will not find a better recreation of the 50's era tweed Fenders. IMO, these (old Fenders) are the best amplifiers ever made, at least for rock and blues type music. The Victoria has all of the tone of the Fender without the reliability associated with a 50 year old amp. They even use the old transformers, carbon resistors, NOS tubes and Jensen speakers.
They make a small 5 watt combo that sounds great and plays as loud as a trumpet. It distorts cleanly and a used version (if you shop around) will probably cost you less than the price of a kit. Plus, unlike a kit, you can re-sell the Victoria for about what you paid. I had a 2010 model and it sounded amazing. I'm still pissed I sold that amp.
I sold mine for $800 but you can find one for around that range. It will hold its value and will only look and sound better with time as the tweed gets battered and scratched up. Here is one that sold on Ebay recently. A bit pricey but, remember, you can pretty much sell it for what you paid or more 5 years from now.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=10171&item=7319187773&rd=1