Hi albee and Tweaker,
I'm one of those who had been crazy about SET tube amps the low power solid state amps driving single driver speakers. Out of curiosity I purchased a ClariT when it wasn't even offered with a 100% money back guarantee. Unimpressed at first, I put it through the use of a TV amplifer for almost 2 months. Afterwards, it's history. In a way it's warm and fleshed out but not like tube nor solid state. It's never sterile, burned in ot not. You're right, as everything else, including super super amps like the Halcro, it's system dependant. Regarding the PFO's 2nd reviewer, I think his speakers are very inadequate for the amp (it's like asking a Porsche 911 to tow a boat, which should be a Ford Explorer's job). And the amp wasn't even broken in, I am sure.
I am not selling my SET nor the solid state amps yet, as I think all of them will shine in the right context. Regarding your burning question,
I think that the battery power lifts the AC noise thus freeing the amp from the grid line related distortions. That for sure will contribute to the "good" sound that appeals to me. The rest of explanation, I would ask either manufacturers like Tripath people, or Vinnie and Wayne who're very talented with modifying the "digital" amps, making them as good as they're today. Of course, I realize there're good sounding digital amps that run off AC power.
Cheers!