Hi, Welcome to the monkey house.
I don't think any cart is future proof if you continue to drop LPs on them. Just kidding, don't be embarrassed, shit happens.
You didn't mention a price range or any type of sound, perhaps referenced to another cart you like?
If I might make a suggestion, replace the stylus in your Clearaudio. There are DIY instructions on the 95 - Clearaudio thread that's right next to this at the moment. Which one do you have?
Even if you want to get a MC it's good to have alternatives and/or something to use while you figure it out.
neo