When you increase the gain of a circuit, you increase the residual thermal noise of the parts in the circuit too (the circuit is dumb, does not know what to amplify, amplifies everthing there is to amplify. You can reduce noise with feedback, but that increases transient distortion too. No way to win.
Regarding the "Grado jiggles". Since the Longhorn stabilizer bar adds about 3 grams of mass to the cartridge, it will likely move the resonant frequency of the arm - cartridge system out of the stylus resonant point and solve that problem for you. Note that the styus assembly is damped too, and that the torsional inertia of the damped stabilizer bar improves mechanical stability too.
If you simply want musical naturalness rather than hi-fi hype and exotic high prices, try our Longhorn Grado, its been working great for 20 years now and still is only $129.00.
Frank Van Alstine