Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 12880 times.

Gopher

Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« on: 17 Jun 2012, 01:48 pm »
I wanted to give you guys a heads up on an a breathtaking new USB DAC in the works from Goto Unit USA.  A name has not yet bet selected for the piece nor has a professional chasis been designed yet, but irrespective of those details the two weeks I spent with the unit in it's wooden project box were two weeks of the best digital reproduction I have ever experienced. 

I was previously a LampizatOr (level 3) owner who liked but never fully loved his DAC.  Discussing this with Ming of Goto USA, and contemplating the move to a Lampizator level 4 dac, he offered me the opportunity to give a listen to and potentially buy a piece he had been working on with the goal of selling commercially in 2013.  The terms of our agreement were that he'd build a fresh unit and send it my way to listen to for two weeks.  If I liked it, I'd send a check for around 50% of what it would eventually retail for and if not, just send it back along with some feedback on the experience...  very fair terms and I jumped on the opportunity.

The unit is a USB DAC, though if necessary SPDIF can be fitted to it.  The designer, Ming believes USB to be the best route feeling adding a receiver chip for the SPDIF only adds another imperfect layer for the signal to pass through.  An excerpt of one of our discussions:

Quote from: Ming
I can add remote volume control and SPDIF input but the more function you add, the more you take away from the music.  At the current design, the digital music get converted from digital to analog and straight out after this D-to-A conversion happen, the music connect to the next stage (preamp or integrated amp) w/o any resistor, capacitor and any other parts that will alter the sound.  In 99.99% of DAC on the market, the music right after the D-to-A conversion, it has to go thru, a capacitor/resistor network to filter out the digital noise generated from the D/A chip.  So, the sound get altered, modified and tone-adjusted/distored in order to get rid of those unwanted digital noise.  In my design, the special transformer also served as digital noise filter, output buffer and hookup wire - so there is really nothing between the sound right out of D/A to the next stage (preamp or integrated amp).  That give you the dynamic, clean and clear transparency and the details of the sound.  Really, there is nothing in between.
 
The reason that I choose to have only one USB input is to avoid adding extra receiver chip before the D/A chip.  In all DAC, the extra receiver chip is just there so the unit can have multiple input types.  The downsize of adding this extra receiver chip is the extra process of the digital signal from your music source.  You finally rip the CD and upgrade the music server and software to be bit-perfect digital signal playback unit.  The music signal is ready to be converted to analog music (D-to-A) but now it has to go thru. this extra receiver device(which is not a 100% perfect device) to introduce more error to the digital signal.  In my view, most of user only use one input type - the rest of the input types are there just in-case but hardly used.  So, if you only use one type of input, such as USB from music server, the single input DAC will provide the best sound quality"

So how did it sound?

It was a revelation.  I have had the opportunity to hear some pretty nice digital gear in my day, but none have pulled off the level of purity, inner detail and just uncolored naturalness that this DAC pulled off with ease.  The noise floor is just non-existant (very welcome change after LampizatOr) and the presentation is dynamic, alive, exciting and completely addictive.  Sterility doesn't enter this equation at any point--and I found it much more fun and enjoyable to listen to then my LampizatOr.

One of the biggest things I noticed is how much the LampizatOr influenced what I listened to.  Finishing almost every listening session with Mark Knoffler or Cowboy Junkies.  With Ming's DAC ALL much was fair game.  I found myself revisiting rock and hip hop I listened to in Junior High school, and the wild part was it all sounded excellent.

I'd always felt my system to be a bit on the polite side, which was something I've been working on voicing out, but with this DAC in place there was not a trace of it.  Everything from Jay-Z to Natalie Merchant were fair game and well reproduced--this thing is killer.

On the second to last day of my trial, I got the opportunity to directly A/B this at a friend's house to an AMR DAP-777.  The GOTO DAC linked via Wywires Ltespeed USB cable to a MacMini and the AMR linked by ASI Liveline to a the LampizatOr Transporter (tubed SPDIF out into tube SPDIF in).  The AMR is a very nice unit, but there was no question in my mind that the GOTO unit was sonically superior being more immediate, dynamic and natural sounding.  It also did a significantly better job of re-creating the venue of the recording (resonant details/room interactions).  This is a major praise as the AMR is no slouch.

I'll update this this thread with more information as it further develops, but I'm still contemplating the purchase...




roscoeiii

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #1 on: 17 Jun 2012, 02:19 pm »
Any idea of ballpark price point?

Gopher

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #2 on: 17 Jun 2012, 02:35 pm »
Not cheap, I think he had the number of $8k in mind. 

Definitely not an impulse purchase, but if you find yourself in that market it needs to be heard.  Its really that good.

jtwrace

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 11424
  • www.theintellectualpeoplepodcast.com
    • TIPP YouTube Channel
Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #3 on: 17 Jun 2012, 02:42 pm »
There are some stellar dac at $4k and under.  To spend $8k seems scary to me.  Is it upgradeable?  DSD?  With the speed of digital I wouldn't spend that kind of money on a dac.  I did it once and will not do it anymore.  There are $1500 dacs that are crazy good.

YMMV

firedog

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #4 on: 17 Jun 2012, 03:09 pm »
There are some stellar dac at $4k and under.  To spend $8k seems scary to me.  Is it upgradeable?  DSD?  With the speed of digital I wouldn't spend that kind of money on a dac.  I did it once and will not do it anymore.  There are $1500 dacs that are crazy good.

YMMV

Yeah, agree with Jason. Just bought a Mytek 192DSD DAC, even after considering some more expensive ones. I basically had 2 considerations: the Mytek does DSD, which means I'm fairly future proofed in terms of formats.  The Mytek is inexpensive compared to some uber DACs, but seems to be in the same ballpark sonically with many more expensive DACs.  I'm very happy with the Mytek so far. The small number of DSD tracks I have sound great, as does PCM.

But so many DACs are coming onto the market - seems like every day there is a new audiophile  one with new features and some new engineering. Just a few days after I ordered mine, I read about the new Lynx DAC/ADC. Has a killer feature set. Supposedly sounds good. Would definitely have given it serious consideration if I'd known about it before I bought.

My conclusion: unless your budget is fairly unlimited, the super expensive DACs are not the way to go. There are DACs for significantly less that probably sound just as good (no claims for looks and bling here with the moderately priced stuff- looks cost money you'll have to spend if that is important to you); and if there aren't today, in another year or two there will be something better than that really expensive DAC that costs less. So invest a moderate amount today, and in a couple  of years invest that same amount again and get something better than today's very expensive DAC. For the total price of one expensive DAC today, you'll end up with a better DAC in two years and a two year period of good sound from the DAC you bought now.

glory

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 50
Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #5 on: 17 Jun 2012, 03:20 pm »
So now all the Walmart shoppers come on a thread like this and take over with the prices are dropping daily remarks.

Ford Focus and Lexus 460 gets you to the Walmart store with 4 rubber tires. Big difference in ride and $$$. For those who have the $$$ the Lexus is the ride of choice.

Let this thread move on without the smell of the Walmart buyer. Let us listen to it for sound sake first.

glory

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 50
Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #6 on: 17 Jun 2012, 03:23 pm »
I have this dac coming to me on Wed.

ASR Emitter 1 Exclusive

Lamp L4/transport

Purepower 1050

Lamp L5 being built to replace L4

Will report my findings.

Gopher

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #7 on: 17 Jun 2012, 03:44 pm »
How to allocate your hard earned dollars is a personal decision  I won't try to influence others on, but I will say this is game changer performance and not something likely duplicated much cheaper.  I'm not sure if I'm supposed to repeat this, but the parts cost of the unit I auditioned is well over $3k already and that's without a nice chassis.

I'll be very interested in your thoughts, Gary and whether this cancels your lampizatOr level 5 order.  I think this dac would be killer in your Zu rig! 

firedog

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #8 on: 17 Jun 2012, 03:52 pm »
So now all the Walmart shoppers come on a thread like this and take over with the prices are dropping daily remarks.

Ford Focus and Lexus 460 gets you to the Walmart store with 4 rubber tires. Big difference in ride and $$$. For those who have the $$$ the Lexus is the ride of choice.

Let this thread move on without the smell of the Walmart buyer. Let us listen to it for sound sake first.

Just like to know how someone who buys a $1500-$2000 DAC is a Walmart shopper. I think you have a warped perspective.

Note no one here talked about getting inferior sound for the money. Simply put, some DACs that are half the price of the $3K and $5K DACs sound just as good. That has no relation to your irrelevant car analogy.

I'm not begrudging anyone who wants to spend $8K on a DAC. Just pointing out that the pace of DAC development may make that a poor use of resources. Again, if your resources allow it, go for it. But if that kind of outlay means you won't be able to get another DAC in the foreseeable future, it may not be the smartest move.


Anyway, my guess is that fully digital amps will start to be more commonplace and better sounding. I wouldn't be surprised if in 5 years you can get a one-box fully digital DAC-Pre-Power for $5K that sounds better than $15-$20K combos of today.

OzarkTom

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #9 on: 17 Jun 2012, 04:56 pm »
Ming sure knows his stuff, I would be very interested in this one.

8K is still a lot cheaper than many of the new LP  anologue systems.

Geardaddy

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #10 on: 17 Jun 2012, 05:01 pm »
"In 99.99% of DAC on the market, the music right after the D-to-A conversion, it has to go thru, a capacitor/resistor network to filter out the digital noise generated from the D/A chip"

I think Ming is onto something.  My unit (dB systems Zardoz) uses that scheme, and it creates great transparency and musicality.

Regarding rapid change in the digital domain as a deterrent to spending money, I think there is some merit to that argument, but then again master tape is still the source to beat after how many years?  I believe it is more a matter of implementation rather than whether you have the dac chip du jour.  Proper implementation, particularly shielding, mechanical grounding, and power supply work takes time and money and you do get what you pay for.  As much as the DIYers like to claim otherwise, you do get what you pay for to some degree

OzarkTom

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #11 on: 17 Jun 2012, 05:07 pm »
Yup, I have never heard a great sounding DAC for under $3500.

glory

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 50
Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #12 on: 17 Jun 2012, 05:08 pm »
Osark,

Great speaker! Heard it at RMAF and was a true disappearing act.

Berto

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #13 on: 17 Jun 2012, 05:56 pm »
I was the friend with the AMR DP-777 that Gopher compared the GOTO DAC too. The GOTO DAC is a incredible piece and IMO blew all my former DACs out of the water in every respect. It is indeed a incredible DAC that really surprised me and at first I preferred the GOTO on almost everything we heard. But this comes with a disclaimer:

My DAC (still needed a few hundred hrs) was NOT fully broken in. Fred (Gopher) was using a Wywire v3 IC on the GOTO DAC. I was NOT using a ASI liveline but another high-end IC. Was not exactly apples to apples until we switched the Wywire V3 (for a even playing field)  my preference went back to the AMR. The WW V3 is quite the difference maker (got one on the way). That IC added the ambience and sense of venue that Fred had mentioned the AMR initially lacked. It was quick a/b with the WW v3 but we were both a lil amazed on how the diff it immed made.

Gopher

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #14 on: 17 Jun 2012, 06:30 pm »
Thanks for Chiming in.  I think I said the ASI was your digital.cable not interconnect.  I agree the wywire 3 helped narrow the gap between the dacs, but it definitely didn't close it in my opinion.  I also could have sworn you said you had 600+ hours on it for our comparison.

The AMR is a smart buy because of how many features it packs while coming close in fidelity but I do not believe it was an equal.

Berto

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #15 on: 17 Jun 2012, 08:22 pm »
Thanks for Chiming in.  I think I said the ASI was your digital.cable not interconnect.  I agree the wywire 3 helped narrow the gap between the dacs, but it definitely didn't close it in my opinion.  I also could have sworn you said you had 600+ hours on it for our comparison.

The AMR is a smart buy because of how many features it packs while coming close in fidelity but I do not believe it was an equal.

The ASI was NOT the digi cable either (currently own a beta cable as a digi). I use a ASI on the pre to amps and that was constant on both DAC demos. AMR had 400+hrs and although it was almost broken in, it was not yet fully stabilized. Undortunately I was told it improves at even 800+ hrs :duh:

I'd still give the dyanmics edge too the GOTO DAC and I admit it was the more impressive sounding piece, but I prefer the bloom/lushness that only comes with tube gear not too mention ability to roll tubes and change flavors.

This reminds me of the comparison of the DUDE vs Shindo preamps. I sold the Shindo b/c I was so impressed with the dynamics of the DUDE. Ultimately I missed that Midrange beauty and sold the DUDE to re-buy the Shindo > call me crazy but that's just my taste and my opinions.


glory

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 50
Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #16 on: 17 Jun 2012, 08:35 pm »
Ozark,

3.5K on the used market is 7K retail. I never buy new and look for at least 40 points. The Amarra 4 dac was a great dac at 2K used.

Live 2 years behind the times and buy at 60% off retail. The great Alpa dac MK1 is going for 2.6K now.

OzarkTom

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #17 on: 17 Jun 2012, 09:25 pm »


My DAC (still needed a few hundred hrs) was NOT fully broken in. Fred (Gopher) was using a Wywire v3 IC on the GOTO DAC. I was NOT using a ASI liveline but another high-end IC. Was not exactly apples to apples until we switched the Wywire V3 (for a even playing field)  my preference went back to the AMR. The WW V3 is quite the difference maker (got one on the way). That IC added the ambience and sense of venue that Fred had mentioned the AMR initially lacked. It was quick a/b with the WW v3 but we were both a lil amazed on how the diff it immed made.

I hate to bring bad news, but the AMR does not fully break-in until at least 900-1000 hours on it. The Zodiac Gold took over 1200 hours.

I hate break-in periods.

OzarkTom

Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #18 on: 17 Jun 2012, 09:38 pm »
Ozark,

3.5K on the used market is 7K retail. I never buy new and look for at least 40 points. The Amarra 4 dac was a great dac at 2K used.

Live 2 years behind the times and buy at 60% off retail. The great Alpa dac MK1 is going for 2.6K now.

The only problem with that theory, the AMR DP-777 at $5K is usually discounted to $4500 and that will beat any of the two year old $7000 Dacs that you can mention.

And the pre-amp section with remote of the AMR has been compared to $8K separate pre-amps. I would rather have the latest technology for the price.

glory

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 50
Re: Incredible new USB DAC from GOTO Unit USA
« Reply #19 on: 17 Jun 2012, 10:03 pm »
Read the feedback on the AMR dac online. Then report back.

Heard a complete AMR system by Darrin and it was OK at best. My friend and I walked out in disbelief on how it was just OK. And it had 23K speaker hooked up to it. His Zu/Atma/Lamp is way better sounding.