The Transcendence Five SLR is indeed a significant improvement over the Super Pas 4i preamp. The board looks the same because it is the same board, the circuitry is quite different as it has been rebiased for 12AT7A tubes and the regulated power supply parts are on the bottom side of the board in this version. A lot of effort has gone into it
Musically the T5 SLR is a lot more transparent and liquid than the 4i and worth the upgrade.
Another observaton, what seems to be the problem with your 4i? It likely will be inexpensive and easy to fix, the overall design is very rugged and durable. You might want to call me about this. 651-330-9871
Frank Van Alstine