I've used various damping rings on my ARC REF3 preamp, but found Herbies tube dampers to perform much better. The sound becomes cleaner with better low level detail, but without the smearing quality and reduction of soundstage I found with damping rings. My impression is that damping rings store and release the vibrational energy resulting in that smearing quality. The tube dampers control the vibrations without returning back to the tubes. By the way, the larger brothers of the Herbies tube dampers work wonders on the T1610 tubes of my Kronzillas, without them they sound broken by comparison. I use three per tube on those, one per tube on my preamp tubes.