0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 9190 times.
Excellent and detailed review Saturn. One thing I'd like to mention from my own personal experience with my HT2-TL's. I've owned mine for just over 2 years now. I was one of the first to get the TL version of the HT2. They have only impressed me from the very first day and they are by far the best audio purchase I've ever made.My HT2-TL's seem to be able to clearly show what your electronics are doing. I would not describe the midrange as you are. I also NEVER hear anything I'd call "muddy." You may be hearing a weakness in your electronics. I'm not saying I'm right, I'm just saying it could be. My Salk's have only gotten better as I have upgraded my front end electronics, which includes cables. I feel like I can hear nearly every subtle change I make. This has proven both great and challenging. Luckily, I have stumbled upon a great mix of gear and cables and I've never been happier. I have the sound I always dreamed of having. Enjoy those wonderful speakers!
I personally would like to thank you and many of the others that have posted extremely detailed reviews. Being a complete newbie (love music but dont really understand at the level you all do) I am spending as much time as I can on these forum posts to learn. I have graduated from my B&W 683's after listening to a Joe Bonamassa DVD and not even coming close to the sound at the concert recently attended.So I'm on the hunt for new and have narrowed it down to either songtowers or HT2-TL's. Budget is a stretch but I want this to be a long term investment.It helps so much to hear true audio purists' postive reviews about the HT2-TL's. They are way more than I need right now but I have always operated under the "buy the best you can afford".Anyway, I just wanted to take the time to say thank you to all that post reviews. You really dont know how much it helps newbie's like me.Good Listening!Spinerep (I sell spinal implants to surgeons)David
Thanks very much for the review. You put almost as much effort into it as you did shopping for speakers! My only question and reservation concerns your remarks about the midrange measurements of the HT2. This is a 2-way speaker, with the crossover point at 2200 Hz. Therefore, any peak in the region you mention (300 - 600 Hz) would be either some kind of inherent inaccuracy in the W18 woofers in that region, a lack of baffle step compensation, or a room peak that doesn't show up on the ADS because it's actually down considerably in that area. I think we can rule out the first two explanations, because the W18's are extremely smooth below 1k, and the HT2's have almost complete baffle step compensation. It's possible that the ADS is depressed in that region (and by more than 2 dB anechoically), because that's probably where the speaker is crossed from the woofer to the midrange. In any event, I've attached a plot of the HT2's anechoic response (which would not reflect room effects). How are you measuring the room response of the speakers? Room plots are very tricky, and are very sensitive to mic position and distance.
i'm with dennis on this one, i'm pretty sure you're hearing room interaction. i am fairly confident in this because i have a very similar room that is almost impossible to get to sound great. my whole house is basically one room, a very open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, crazy angles, and an open lofted second floor. i just watched a video on the site of the "get better sound" guy, jim smith, in which he describes it's very unlikely to get great sound in a room like this. sadly, i have learned that when a speaker sounds great in a "normal" room, it will just sound "very good" at best in mine. just something i have to live with. that doesn't mean i (and you) can't optimize what we do have, though (hence my HT2-TL's).BTW, dave seemed to indicate that he could financially swing the more expensive ones, so why shouldn't he? they are worth the price diff IMO (and many others i think). i will absolutely agree that if he had to get the song's he would be happy with them - they are excellent speakers too.
Perhaps once my wallet recovers, I might experiment with room treatments. Can room treatments help flatten the rise in the range I mentioned?
dave, if you are thinking long term get the HT2's. they really are better speakers (not just speakers that go lower). the songs are great, but the HT2's are in a higher league. nice review, saturn. glad to see someone not afraid to point out the high points AND the low points that they hear.
You bet they can. So can experimenting with placement of the speakers and the LP. Even six inches can make a drastic change.That was an awesome review, Saturn; well worth the wait! Thanks so much for sharing your journey with us, and once again, welcome to the Salk family. Whoot!
^ What preamp are you currently running, BRM? The BAT VK3i?