The Red ones aren't a piano finish, but they are a gloss finish that Earl was trying out. Not mirror smooth, they do have some imperfections. I'm considering having someone refinish them to a Piano black finish.
Edit: Just noticed Earls response. Yes, his desciption is spot on, there are some minor imperfections, and he gave me the choice for this new finish and I accepted. Hindsight being 20/20,I should have gone with Black. Even with the Gloss finish, it doesn't interfere with my projector though but I have my Abbeys spaced pretty widely to the sides of my screen.