I think that you are referring to the anti-skate setting, which should match the tracking weight.
By the Shure gauge, I think that you are referring to a scale to measure the tracking weight. Does it measure the tracking weight, i.e.; the downward weight on the tonearm? The anti-skate is the tracking "bias", i.e.; the sideward force/pressure, which is adjusted by the slider on the side of the tonearm.
Slide the anti-skate to zero. Turn the weight on the back of the tonearm until the tonearm is level (floats). Then, turn the weight on the back of the tonearm, using the Shure scale, after you calibrate the scale to zero, until the Shure scale indicates that the downward weight is 1.5 or 1.6. You are now done with the Shure scale. Then, move the anti-skate "slider", on the side of the tonearm, to as close to 1.5 or 1.6 as you can approximate. You are done, assuming that the cartridge is properly aligned in the arm.