0 Members and 5 Guests are viewing this topic. Read 548827 times.
New to this circle, and pretty new to AudioCircle generally (arriving via Salk Sound). Anyway, working my way through Andras Schiff's Schubert set for a second time. For those who go for sets (I go for sets and individual discs - I want it all), this is among the best to my ears, in the same category as Wilhelm Kempff, Michael Endres, and Christian Zacharias.
If you really like the Schubert sonatas, you owe it to yourself to hear the Maurizio Polini version on DG. It may be a little more animated for your taste if you really like Schiff, but you should check them out.
I have Pollini's DG Schubert and enjoy it quite a bit. I can't say that he matches the great readings of the individual works (Brendel in 959, Kovacevich [Hyperion or EMI] or Richter [Salzburg 1972] in 960, to name a few), but he offers quite a bit. I find Pollini supremely controlled, as usual. If I want really animated Schubert, I can always go for Gulda's few recordings.
You and I seem to be on a similar wavelength in music. Quite good insight in this thread. Do you read music?
Any thoughts on Uchida for Schubert?
I'm not a big fan of Uchida, and I find much of her Schubert, like much of her solo Mozart, to be too quirky and/or disjointed for me. It rarely flows in many of the bigger late works, and she isn't lyrical enough in some others (D664 comes to mind). That written, D845 and D850 are quite well done.