Do I Need to Specify?

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 729 times.

Mag

Do I Need to Specify?
« on: 10 Dec 2008, 11:39 pm »
If I make a recommendation for a cd album, saying it sounds incredible. Do I need to specify that my opinion is based on listening in MC stereo?  An audiophile with only 2 speakers in a 2 channel stereo may not hear what I'm hearing if they go out and buy the cd.

It is not my fault if the majority of audiophiles have confined themselves to listening to stereo with just 2 measly speakers rather than stereo with 10 speakers.

What should I do?

satfrat

  • Restricted
  • Posts: 10855
  • Boston Red Sox!! 2004 / 2007 / 2013
Re: Do I Need to Specify?
« Reply #1 on: 10 Dec 2008, 11:41 pm »
If I make a recommendation for a cd album, saying it sounds incredible. Do I need to specify that my opinion is based on listening in MC stereo?  An audiophile with only 2 speakers in a 2 channel stereo may not hear what I'm hearing if they go out and buy the cd.

It is not my fault if the majority of audiophiles have confined themselves to listening to stereo with just 2 measly speakers rather than stereo with 10 speakers.

What should I do?

Provide samples of said album and let folks make up their own minds, simple as that. But if you think the album's awesome, hell say so. :D

Cheers,
robin

satfrat

  • Restricted
  • Posts: 10855
  • Boston Red Sox!! 2004 / 2007 / 2013
Re: Do I Need to Specify?
« Reply #2 on: 10 Dec 2008, 11:43 pm »
As far as how many speakers you're using, who gives a crap? That's personal choice, let the music stand on it's own merit. :thumb:


From 1 multichannel guy to another. 8)

Cheers,
Robin

Dan Driscoll

Re: Do I Need to Specify?
« Reply #3 on: 11 Dec 2008, 03:55 pm »
As far as how many speakers you're using, who gives a crap? That's personal choice, let the music stand on it's own merit. :thumb:


I listen to both MC and stereo music, I do give a crap and I'm sure there are others. I especially care when referring to older music that was recorded and mastered on analog tape. Without the original single track tapes, which usually no longer exist, they have to use the master tape (assuming it still exists) to create the MC master. But virtually all of those older masters are in stereo or mono and they often sound like shit when re-mastered into MC. Also, many older recordings were often laid down with all of the instruments and even the vocals on a single tape. Re-mastering those into MC is almost impossible, you get stupid effects, like lead vocals coming from the surrounds.   :slap:

A perfect example would be Sonny Rollins' Saxophone Colossus, one of, if not the finest recording ever made. But it was recorded in mono and every single stereo re-master I've heard has sounded like absolute garbage when compared to the original mono. However, there's no accounting for taste, because some people do actually prefer the stereo versions. :shake:

OTOH, digital recordings or in cases where all of the original single track analog tapes do still exist is a different situation. It is much easier to manipulate those and separate out the individual instruments and vocals. Those can sound very good in MC.  :thumb:

PhilNYC

Re: Do I Need to Specify?
« Reply #4 on: 11 Dec 2008, 04:07 pm »
Maybe when making the recommendation, you could comment on some of the things you hear based on a multi-channel listening experience that you think are noteworthy differentiators from listening to the same music in 2-channel. 

That said, if I read a comment that says "this is incredible music in multi-channel, but sucks in 2-channel", my bet is that the music probably isn't very good...