Yup, isolation (however achieved) and ruler flat leveling pays off
tremendous dividends for turntables (
especially belt drivers on the leveling part). Best thing of all, as you now found, it's practically
free/gratis/zilch/nada/zippo to achieve with a few things around your home.
It really doesn't take much at all to get real music from vinyl...isolation, arm/cartridge geometry, and leveling are primary keys to it. Once you have a
minimally acceptable cartridge after getting these factors right....other (more expensive) upgrades like a 'better' cartridge, vastly more expensive deck, record cleaning machines, 'better' arm, etc. add only little nuances of pleasure to vinyl's musicality. The van Alstine Longhorn, damping the coils of some cartridges with silicone 1000cst, and the Plast-i-Lator are all nearly free tweeks that will improve what you already have a bit further.
The more expensive upgrades/tweeks help the cause a bit.....but you're paying a lot for less return in musicality than you might hope for excess moola' spent.
Disclosure: I believe in arm damping as a general rule,own a record cleaning machine, have a bevy of cartridges I swap out from $60 - $200....so it's not as though I don't recognize benefits from 'upgrades'...only that they are working within a law of diminishing returns for money spent over the basic set up with good isolation, arm/cartridge geometry, and leveling done.
When I hear someone ditched their TT set-up for digital it's either because the convenience of CD was too hard to ignore, or they hadn't had their (even modest) TT/arm set up right in the first place. It's not because vinyl is in totality inferior to CD....it's just a matter of preference, convenience or incorrect set-up. Unlike CD, which is mostly plug in and play (wonderful in that regard) a Turntable is a mechanical device requiring far more efforts to get dialed in right. It's likewise the dual nature of turntables....it's a PITA to set up, but once you got it, you realize how much less musical CD playback is.
That's been
my experience at least