Dennis,
I wouldn't replace the cap at all. Auricaps are very good quality, and it's very unlikely to be faulty, to be honest.
It may also be that your mains power is hiking up and down; SA has a compromised grid at present, particularly during winter months when demand from electrical heat pumps is high. Remember, output offset on the AKSA does move up and down with mains; it's always safe because of the tolerance in the system, but it does move up and down and I never even pay any attention to it these days.
Hope this allays your fears!! How does it sound? Do you like it?
Cheers,
Hugh