Five into Two

d55124

Five into Two
« on: Yesterday at 04:54 pm »
As I approach my late ‘70’s, I feel an overwhelming need to simplify things.  From my T10 RB pre/NP1 amp/DAC Mk5/Audiolab transport and occasional Sony Blue Ray player five box system, I set a goal towards a two box only system.  Research suggested several of the newer $400-$600 cd players were pretty good and, of course, AVA integrated (Control) amp a must.

I settled on a SET 120 Control amp which I long had in my sites fueled by the newly released Onkyo CD-30 player selected mainly cause of the AKM chip (albeit a lesser chip than the 4490 in the DAC Mk5).  Long owned speakers by Harbeth (P3ESR SEs).

I figured the weakest link in this proposal would be the DAC so set up a challenge to see what I could live with (the DAC mk5 is really, really good).  Decided to give the latest internet craze (SMSL SU-1 which houses the latest AKM 4490 series chip) a try.  About the size of a deck of poker cards. All for about $85.  Amazon delivered in a few days.

The first shootout - this wonder DAC vs. the Mk5.  Music provided by Diana Krall and other intimate female vocalists, Janis Ian from the ‘60’s, many Jazz pianists and combo groups, along with a few jazz guitar giants.  Nothing too “orchestra-like”.  The SU-1 is indeed a wonder (wonder how so many could fall in love with it!).  It had all the frequency extensions of a modern DAC, but was somewhat harsh and flat - could not listen too long as the Mk5 put it too shame too often ($1200 vs $80 so be it). Back to Amazon it goes.  Had to try though.

Next up the Onyko vs the Mk5.  A much, much closer scenario.  The Mk5 still a little smoother and more relaxed, but by a very slim margin.  I was impressed.

Search over!  Two boxes it is!

jmc207

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 411
Re: Five into Two
« Reply #1 on: Today at 12:45 am »
Congrats on your new combo! I'm trying to point myself in that direction as well.

I.Greyhound Fan

Re: Five into Two
« Reply #2 on: Today at 05:10 am »
Not surprising that the smsl dac sounded like it did.  I bought an ASR recommend E50.  It sounds good with a receiver and sub $1k speakers in my bedroom. But when my son and I put it in both our reference systems, it sounded muddy and harsh.

So many people think that all dacs sound the same or there is little difference. They may also not have the gear to expose it.