jedger
You stated "There is no hum when only the amp (Van Alstine solid state Synergy 240) is on, no hum when only the preamp is on."
This tells me that the power amp is fine. The way we test power amps for noise is to ground the input (which in your case, I believe, is the same as turning the preamp off).
Note that an open input is NOT the same as a grounded input. Most AVA power amps will be quite noisy if the inputs are open (even though they do have pull down resistors).
That leaves a noisy preamp or a ground issue.
Number one suspect would be a tube in the preamp. There is a strong possibility that this would only cause the noise in one channel though.
Number two would probably be ground: in a typical stereo chain - source, preamp, power amp, speakers - one, and only one, component should be connected directly to earth ground. If multiple components are each connected to earth ground there is a possibility of a ground loop. You can disconnect the component from earth ground by flipping the ground switch (down = off) on most AVA gear or by using a 3 to 2 prong adapter cube thingie (which is the same as old school cutting the ground prong off -which you are not suppose to do anymore).
Dan