Over the years, I've wondered whether there was a need for a product that offered equalization focused on correcting issues with room acoustics…And now that things have shifted so dramatically to the digital realm -- with folks applying whatever EQ they need from their streamers, apps, or other digital sources -- I'm not sure how much need there is for something like this anymore…
Anyone else?
I may be an outlier in this hobby, or at least the subset of hobbyists who populate related forums, but this portion of an indirect competitor product description sums up my experience and level of patience for fiddling with stuff, especially EQ/DSP.
“Yes, tone control. As in, equalizer…And yeah, we know you can get a surgical software EQ, but the 6 knobs here just sit on your desk and beckon. No apps, no graphic confusion…”
My digital front end incorporates graphic/PEQ (part of the buying decision) but the actual interfaces are several menus deep, they aren’t as intuitive as they at first appear, and/or they simply do not respond in an intuitive fashion. Maybe I’m a too impatient old dog but in this respect the equipment simply gets in the way of enjoying some music.
EQ of digital in the digital domain of course makes sense. But at some level the nth degree of resolution, noise, or whatever distortion just doesn’t matter and inserting something in the analog signal path isn’t heresy.
It wasn’t until a couple of months ago when I was fitted for hearing aids that I realized how much I had been missing. Yet I agonized over every silly little system and/or setup change in the preceding years because I failed to hear any differences. Well duh. First things first.
In a nod to a significant demographic, there are umpteen threads on audiophile hearing aids and such which, for me, just adds another layer and level of frustration. If for no other reason than they are only active to 8K I don’t like to listen through the hearing aids.
Many in this hobby value the fussing and tweaking. It’s part of their enjoyment. That just isn’t me. So I use, within its limits, a simple 6 band analog tone control to mimic my hearing aid program. It’s imperfect at best and more akin to the Quad shape control but it works for me.
Specific to room acoustics and getting back on topic, I agree DSP is probably the best. But room acoustics goes way beyond simple FR corrections and practical DSP applications probably go beyond room corrections. How about importing and overlaying hearing aid programs on room corrections?
While DSP may dominate for good reason, I will argue that it isn’t for everyone.