Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?

DeeJayBump and 5 Guests are viewing this topic. Read 109184 times.

jmimac351

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 751
  • Chief Instructor ChinTrackDays
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #360 on: 11 Oct 2025, 02:21 pm »
I just bypassed the volume control which made a big difference. This amp is awesome.

I was going to ask if you did that.  I saw mention of that improving it.  So far I have been able to resist buying one.  And then I start rationalizing the nice case and how that is worth money by itself.   :D

I think these are the output transistors in it.  Bipolar. 

Does it sound like it is putting out 20w/ch into 8ohm?

https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/onsemi/MJL21193/606091

mkrawcz

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 623
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #361 on: 11 Oct 2025, 02:51 pm »
mkrawcz, you have a nice little collection of amps, (mostly class A?), I’d be interested in a little pros/cons comparison 😇😎. Also, what are you listening on?
I listen on NX-Oticas, NX-Studios, NX-Bravos, NX-Bravo Towers, Superminis, Brutes, upgraded Magnepan LRS+, Caladans, and modded Sony sscs5 mostly. I have a number of other speakers, but they sit unused most of the time(probably time to start cleaning house). I have somewhere around 30 amps with an equal split of tube, class A, AB, and D. My general preference is  Tube and Class A. They sound more convincingly real and natural. The closest class d amps I have that knock at the door are probably the Hypex Nilai and NCx500 amps, they soften the edges just a bit more than the Purifi amps making them a little less “etched”. The funny thing is that the Douk Audio A5 with upgraded opamps is really close to those amps at a fraction of the price. The Pass First Watt amps tend to be the closest Class A amps to really good tube amps but without the expense of constantly buying tubes which is why I prefer them overall. The thing I have found is there is no perfect amp for all types of music which is why I rotate around constantly. Tubes and Class A for jazz and classical, class D for rock.

mkrawcz

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 623
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #362 on: 11 Oct 2025, 02:56 pm »
I was going to ask if you did that.  I saw mention of that improving it.  So far I have been able to resist buying one.  And then I start rationalizing the nice case and how that is worth money by itself.   :D

I think these are the output transistors in it.  Bipolar. 

Does it sound like it is putting out 20w/ch into 8ohm?

https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/onsemi/MJL21193/606091
It actually sounds a lot more powerful than 20 watts. I see it’s now $250 on Amazon, totally worth it. I will have to dig into it and figure out some stuff to tweak, I almost don’t want to mess with it too much beyond replacing the wiring and binding posts.

nlitworld

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 2586
  • Strange things are afoot at the Circle K
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #363 on: 11 Oct 2025, 03:37 pm »
Just got this little 20 watt class A amp that is allegedly a clone of the Musical Fidelity A1 without the preamp section. BRZHifi A1S, cost $225 on Amazon and I am shocked at how good it is.

I don't need a new amp... I don't need a new amp... If I say it enough times, I'll start believing it, right? I've seen this one before but never thought to jump on it. I haven't yet owned a pure class A ss amp, and an affordable (and tweakable) option such as this could be a fun little piece. After I finish my other amp projects (tubes4hifi ST35 and more Douk A5 mods & custom case) I may give this a go.  :thumb:

goggle1824

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 85
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #364 on: 11 Oct 2025, 04:10 pm »
I listen on NX-Oticas, NX-Studios, NX-Bravos, NX-Bravo Towers, Superminis, Brutes, upgraded Magnepan LRS+, Caladans, and modded Sony sscs5 mostly. I have a number of other speakers, but they sit unused most of the time(probably time to start cleaning house). I have somewhere around 30 amps with an equal split of tube, class A, AB, and D. My general preference is  Tube and Class A. They sound more convincingly real and natural. The closest class d amps I have that knock at the door are probably the Hypex Nilai and NCx500 amps, they soften the edges just a bit more than the Purifi amps making them a little less “etched”. The funny thing is that the Douk Audio A5 with upgraded opamps is really close to those amps at a fraction of the price. The Pass First Watt amps tend to be the closest Class A amps to really good tube amps but without the expense of constantly buying tubes which is why I prefer them overall. The thing I have found is there is no perfect amp for all types of music which is why I rotate around constantly. Tubes and Class A for jazz and classical, class D for rock.

Awesome, thanks so much for sharing your thoughts and experiences on all of this, this summary is exactly what I was hoping for! 🍻🙌🏼

Given your amps experience, I’m curious, have you heard a FW Aleph J or a good version of the DIY version?

BrandonB

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 491
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #365 on: 11 Oct 2025, 05:06 pm »
I don't need a new amp... I don't need a new amp... If I say it enough times, I'll start believing it, right? I've seen this one before but never thought to jump on it. I haven't yet owned a pure class A ss amp, and an affordable (and tweakable) option such as this could be a fun little piece. After I finish my other amp projects (tubes4hifi ST35 and more Douk A5 mods & custom case) I may give this a go.  :thumb:
Sounds like you need a new amp!

BrandonB

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 491
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #366 on: 11 Oct 2025, 05:19 pm »

Not touching source components, yet. I am very happy with my source gear and happy with the money I have in it. 

I recall you had a full lineup of Ayre.  What is your current setup including your source gear?

NXSTUDIO-DRUMMER

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 229
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #367 on: 11 Oct 2025, 05:33 pm »
Just got this little 20 watt class A amp that is allegedly a clone of the Musical Fidelity A1 without the preamp section. BRZHifi A1S, cost $225 on Amazon and I am shocked at how good it is. This beats all the cheap class D amps you will find on Amazon by a mile. I see some opportunity to tweak also. Playing it through the NX-Bravo Towers and it’s very much a high end sounding Class A amp. Still can’t believe this cost so little. Just the chassis alone is something that would cost about $200 for DIY.


I'm curiouos how much better does this amp sound compared to a $80 Douk Audio A5 for sale on Amazon?

One would hope it sounds better, since it over 2 1/2 times the cost of the A5. Question is how much better though?  By far it looks more impressive, literally in all categories IMHO. It would be interesting to compare both heads up. I've invested $59.00 in upgrades on my A5, upgraded the op amps , added a Acopian 48 volt / 8 1/2 amp linear supply, $130.00 total, including the A5 purchase. Even so, it's still less than $225.00 with upgrades, making this mini amp pretty impressive sounding for the price too. Playing the A5 through the NX-Studio's, or my Mordaunt Short speakers is damn impressive, for what I've invested.

I can't imagine the A1S is that much better? If it is, without doubt it's a best kept secret. For obvious reasons, you can't compare in terms of power, hands down my A5 is more substancial, with a 26lb acopian regulated linear power supply providing over 300 watts cllean watts. Compairing the circuit designs, laughable, the A1S is more impressive. I wish someone owned both to do a real heads up comparison.

Even my other Acopian LPS below does a hell of a job too.




mkrawcz

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 623
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #368 on: 11 Oct 2025, 06:01 pm »
I'm curiouos how much better does this amp sound compared to a $80 Douk Audio A5 for sale on Amazon?

One would hope it sounds better, since it over 2 1/2 times the cost of the A5. Question is how much better though?  By far it looks more impressive, literally in all categories IMHO. It would be interesting to compare both heads up. I've invested $59.00 in upgrades on my A5, upgraded the op amps , added a Acopian 48 volt / 8 1/2 amp linear supply, $130.00 total, including the A5 purchase. Even so, it's still less than $225.00 with upgrades, making this mini amp pretty impressive sounding for the price too. Playing the A5 through the NX-Studio's, or my Mordaunt Short speakers is damn impressive, for what I've invested.

I can't imagine the A1S is that much better? If it is, without doubt it's a best kept secret. For obvious reasons, you can't compare in terms of power, hands down my A5 is more substancial, with a 26lb acopian regulated linear power supply providing over 300 watts cllean watts. Compairing the circuit designs, laughable, the A1S is more impressive. I wish someone owned both to do a real heads up comparison.

Even my other Acopian LPS below does a hell of a job too.

I have the Douk A5. One isn’t necessarily better than the other. The Douk A5 is more neutral with precision pinpoint imaging and instrument placement. The A1S is more about the vivid midrange that comes from 2nd harmonic distortion. Once you hear it, it’s hard to not continue wanting it. It’s why people like tube amps so much. That distortion profile makes vocals and orchestral instruments sound more real like they’re actually in the room and not a recording.

NXSTUDIO-DRUMMER

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 229
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #369 on: 11 Oct 2025, 06:22 pm »
Refreshing to know one has both amps, providing us an evaluation. Thanks for you input, distinguishing the differences between the two amp's characteristics. The feedback you've contributed, will certainly help others in the marketplace shopping around.

I will say this regarding the A5, one is truly missing out not using the A5 connected up with a tube preamp. It helps it deliver what you described,
"makes vocals and orchestral instruments sound more real like they’re actually in the room and not a recording."

Note:
If your not planning on using a preamplifier with an A5, At least upgrade the attenuator, with a higher quality one. The stock one does degrade the signal somewhat. Using a nice tube preamp connected however, one should position the setting on the A5 to full volume. Now your preamp's attenuator will adust the volume, bypassing the A5's attenuator, eleviates signal degradation.
« Last Edit: 11 Oct 2025, 10:32 pm by NXSTUDIO-DRUMMER »

jmimac351

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 751
  • Chief Instructor ChinTrackDays
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #370 on: 14 Oct 2025, 01:41 am »
I recall you had a full lineup of Ayre.  What is your current setup including your source gear?

That's a lot of words, if what you're asking is "WHY" I've made a few changes.  I'll share that with you.  I'll go thru each piece and what I like about it, what it maybe led me to do in terms of direction.  When I have some time think about it I'll share.  Maybe it will help someone.

Bottom line... and it made Danny chuckle when I mentioned it to him as we were talking about some piece of gear...

"I like Charlie's & Ariel's preamps, Nelson's amps, and Danny's speakers." 

I happen to think you can throw a dart at each of those brands / equipment categories, bring home whatever piece you hit, put it all together and have sound you can live with for the rest of your life.

And then... there was the DAC I found out the name of over the weekend that Nelson mentioned while I was watching a Zoom presentation of his at Burning Amp.  I didn't catch the name but I heard enough... he said "Game Changer".  Nelson doesn't say that about anything, not that starkly at least.  Evidently the DAC is quite "immersive".  "170dB".  And it's DESIGNED to run direct into amps.  Alien technology, obviously. Stuff like that comes up and then you "rethink everything".  But you gotta keep your head cool!  After I get one I will let you know whether it "transforms the industry". :lol: Nelson agrees.  How can you "not" want to hear something like that?  8)

I have and have had a lot of pretty good junk.  I'd like to think I have learned some secrets and very smart money for how to get "it". 

Another thing though, in the meantime... it is very hard to parse words from another's opinion and be happy with an equipment choice - unless you also own what they like... you have SHARED EXPERIENCE... but you have to actually experience the stuff.  What if the person you're allowing to influence you is a moron?  There are a few... I've noticed.

Money needs to be set aside, used gear needs to be bought and sold for the right price, continue cycle until you learn enough / find "IT".

What I am doing right now is putting a lot of money back in my pocket, because I have experienced and learned things.  "Smart Money". 

Huskerbryce

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 118
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #371 on: 14 Oct 2025, 03:21 am »
170db??   Do you have an Imersiv D1 DAC??  I want to hear one.

jmimac351

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 751
  • Chief Instructor ChinTrackDays
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #372 on: Yesterday at 12:45 am »
170db??   Do you have an Imersiv D1 DAC??  I want to hear one.

Not yet. I need to see if it will be happy with the amps I am liking.  It it supposed to be run DIRECT, and with the amps I like that could be a challenge. 

The ones with issues may be my First Watt SIT-3, First Watt SIT-5, and the Sony VFET amp will be here Friday.  All are single ended input.  That is a challenge with that DAC.  The 170db is at BALANCED.  It specifically mentioned the RCA output is not the same performance as Balanced, out of that device.  It's the way it's designed. 

The Imersiv manual seems to mention I can make it work by adding balanced inputs electrically.  I've asked Nelson Pass about it.  See the "Advisory Board" on the Imeriv website. 

The other issue is the Imersiv wants amps with >20dB gain, and preferably 30dB.  It's so the volume level of the Imeriv runs in lower gain, which has better performance window.  The SIT-5 are my best amps, and have 19dB gain.  The SIT-3 is only 11.5db gain.  Many of the other DIY amps are lower gain.  Probably not an issue with my "best amps" SIT-5, but it's still single ended input too... have to solve Balanced input question.  With "regular amps" and regular input gain, none of that is a problem - but it needs to be differentially balanced.  Balanced "for real".  We'll see.

This DAC... I mentioned that Advisory Board and there is also a User section.  For any and all... go read the endless comments from recording industry Pros.

Here: https://imersiv.com/user-comments/

It's obvious that what jumps out is that they say how incredible it is, "never heard anything like it"... OVER THE TOP comments. And they go on and on and on. 

But there were other comments sprinkled in that I think are very telling.  Several of them mentioned that at the "top levels" of gear, there is very little difference... "they all sound the same". 

THAT is why I want to hear that DAC. It's very likely to be very different.  And I think because so much stuff sounds the same, people keep buying and selling in search of "IT", only to hear the same old thing again... that the YouTube guy said was "IT".

THAT is also why I am liking the First Watt stuff so much.  It is DIFFERENT, on purpose, with a nice dose of Negative Phase 2nd Order Harmonic. 

Reading thru the First Watt papers... if one spends time reading the First Watt amp manuals.  Nelson explains the purpose of the amp, why it's different, and he tells a lot of the "Why?".  Another thing you'll notice, starting with the first SIT-1, is he found people really seemed to like NEGATIVE PHASE 2nd order harmonics. 

It seems to add very pleasing effects to Depth and Soundstage.  Our brains seem to process 2nd Order Harmonic distortion that way. He also very proudly sez.... "the ASR crowd is gonna hate this amp, and it sounds great!".  :green:

And... that is why the .8 series came out with a little sprinkle of "that sound".  However, some still like the .5 series. 

It is really hard to parse words on a brand new, $12,000 DAC to make a decision whether to try it... because you have to listen.

Huskerbryce

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 118
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #373 on: Yesterday at 03:02 am »
Yes, I’ve spent a lot of money on a lot of equipment over the years, trying to achieve audio Nirvana. All of it was only to find that it kinda all sounded the same. The first moment of audio Bliss that I had was when I took the plunge and built a pair of Danny‘s NX Otica speakers. Suddenly, I was wowed by the cost to sound ratio. I was listening to music that I was intimately familiar with and it sounded way beyond my past threshold of wow.   My multi thousand dollar mono blocks came alive. I was about ready to sell them off. I think there is a value to some things in the audio world and I’ve listened to many different digital to analog converters claiming to be the “it” factor.  Most were meh….That left much to be desired. So I am skeptical about the new $12k imersiv…   Hoping you buy one so I can get an idea of what its all about

Craig Young

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 59
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #374 on: Yesterday at 04:41 am »
My current preamp and amp is going to be accompanied by AGD and Aric. I am currently listening to Roon via Schiit Freya+ to Aegir. I am getting AGD Duets to run with my Freya+. In the near future I am planning on getting Aric Motherlode XL and which tier?

BrandonB

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 491
Re: Solid State or Tubes with your NX-series speakers?
« Reply #375 on: Yesterday at 07:34 pm »

It's obvious that what jumps out is that they say how incredible it is, "never heard anything like it"... OVER THE TOP comments. And they go on and on and on. 
THAT is why I want to hear that DAC. It's very likely to be very different.  And I think because so much stuff sounds the same, people keep buying and selling in search of "IT", only to hear the same old thing again... that the YouTube guy said was "IT".
I read some articles last night about this DAC and was  intrigued.  I don't understand all the science but I could follow along with some of it out.  I posted about it in a few forum's and people acted like "ah I've seen that old thing before and all kinds of DAC's have more than one chip".  I guess people only process half of what they read....lol  Have you spoke to anyone about it in person?