2018 Oscars

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 412 times.

Rob Babcock

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 9131
2018 Oscars
« on: 6 Mar 2018, 04:44 am »
Well, this year I missed quite a few of the Oscar-nominated films.  I was working out of town in a little village with just a single movie house with three screens.  So while I missed some of them I will post some impressions of the ones I did see:

1) Best Picture- The winner was The Shape of Water.  I really enjoyed the film.  It was a technical tour de force and the kind of love letter to movies that always get the Academy drooling. All the performances were outstanding and the film was very good.  The best of the year?  Eh, hard to say.  So far I haven't had a chance to see I, Tonya or Three Billboards so I can't say.  My sense is that it was a great movie that perhaps fell a little short of what you'd expect in a BP winner but overall I can't say it was undeserving.

2) Best Actor- Again, didn't get to see Phantom Thread but of course any time DDL is nominated he's the favorite.  Gary Oldman is a brilliant actor and he was widely praised this year but I missed Darkest Hours as well.  I did see Get Out and it was so strong that part of me thinks it should have shown a little better with awards.

3) Best Original Screenplay- Jordan Peele of course made history as the first African American to ever win this in the 90 year history of the Academy but it was certainly no affirmative action award!  Get Out was unmitigated genius!  It's hard to believe this sprang fully formed from a 1st time director and screenwriter!  I see very big things ahead of Peele.

4) Cinematography- The technical awards probably just go over most people's heads but it was gratifying to see Roger Deakins finally win!  His work as DP on Bladerunner 2049 was mesmerizing, but then again it always is.  He's the unsung genius behind so many revered directors.  It's time to see him get his due.

5) Director- Guillermo del Toro is a genius, full stop.  I've admired his work for decades, and certainly any time he's nominated he's probably deserving of a win.

Sadly I can't really comment on many more categories and I didn't have a chance to see a lot of the films in the running.  Still I was a little surprised that Dunkirk won practically nothing as I thought it was one of the better films of the year.  I was also a little bit irritated at the politicization of much of the ceremony.  Without dragging politics in I'll cite just won example that irked me a bit; when Jennifer Lawrence listed all the men as a block for director and pointed only liste the single woman by name.  I get it, there should be more women nominated and more women directors in total.  But without perhaps meaning to slight anyone it seems in poor taste to cast shade on the very rare African American to ever even get a nomination for Best Director.  And in a field that hews white it seems like a real slight to cast aspersions on del Toro since Hispanics are maybe more underrepresented even than women.

Still, it was an interesting season. I hope to see Three Billboards soon and also Lady Bird.

zoom25

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 775
Re: 2018 Oscars
« Reply #1 on: 6 Mar 2018, 05:08 am »
I loved Dunkirk. It did end up winning Oscars for Sound Editing and Sound Mixing. Well deserved. I watched it on 70mm film in IMAX. It was intense! By far the loudest experience I've had in that theatre and I've been going there for the last 18 years sitting in the same spot.

The only other movie I've watched from the list is Get Out. That was good as well. I'm looking forward to watching the rest.  :thumb:

brother love

Re: 2018 Oscars
« Reply #2 on: 6 Mar 2018, 02:37 pm »
Without dragging politics in I'll cite just won example that irked me a bit; when Jennifer Lawrence listed all the men as a block for director and pointed only liste the single woman by name.

Actually, it was Emma Stone who made that statement.  Also, there were no female director Golden Globe nominees, & Natalie Portman said here are the all-male nominees. While both were rude in slighting those men who were nominated, I personally support women taking a stand for more equality & recognition.

Get Out was my personal fave of the nominations, but I also didn't see all the nominated films.

Rob Babcock

  • Volunteer
  • Posts: 9131
Re: 2018 Oscars
« Reply #3 on: 6 Mar 2018, 08:25 pm »
Yeah, I knew it was Stone but misspoke- thanks.  I support equality as well but I feel Stone's comments were rude.  I think Portman's were understandable given the lack of any female noms when certainly there were deserving women.  Anyway, I suppose there those that though Rosa Parks was being rude as well so I don't want to overstate it.