Since I have had the BCD-1 for six years and have had only one hiccup with it,I'd vote for the BCD-1.
BUT,since having the BDP-2,the sound is just as if not better than the BCD-1.
I also had the BDA-1 dac and use to compare the BCD to the BDA dac(hard pressed to hear a difference).
The BDP-2 and BDA-2 are so much more convenient especially if you have to look thru a few hundred cds for one song.
the BDP-2 whether I'm upstairs or down I can make long playlists of exactly what I want to hear

I know I've had a few troubles with my BDP-2,which did piss me off as I like listening to music a lot.
For me a CDP seems so Neanderthal now compared to the BDP's,seems I can't be without out it as I use to really depend on the BCD-1 heavily for playback.
Would I buy another cdp,NO as in an emergency I can use my Oppos for back up and try to find that one song out of 540 cd's.
I will(just in case buy another BDP )as it is just sounds to good.
Plus the CONVENIENCE of selecting songs and making a list to satisfy hrs of exactly of what I want to hear without going through all those cds.
Reminds of going thr a few hundred LPS for one cut

,which I might spin twice a yr if I'm lucky on a 11,000 TT and PH stage.
BDP's are the Cat's as for me and I never thought of giving up my BCD-1,gee thanks Robert

.