I've only had this issue on new records, recent YepRoc release of Robyn Hitchcock, a hole so tight I could barely get it on my Linn. Then, Merriweather Post Pavilion from Animal Collective had a bunch of flash still hanging out of the hole. And a couple of other new releases bordered on snug.
I thought maybe there was a pattern. I've had the turntable for over 30 years and never remembered it being an issue "back in the day." But heck, there's a lot of stuff I can't remember from back then...lol
Paul