SongTower veneer choices

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 1619 times.

safebelayer

  • Jr. Member
  • Posts: 10
SongTower veneer choices
« on: 7 Dec 2011, 09:18 pm »
I'm wondering if there's a difference in sound quality or just sound with the use of any of the veneer choices.  Does bamboo, walnut, satin black, etc present different sound?  Also, the satin black finish, is that with a a particular wood type veneer (showing wood grain like many speaker manufacturers use when they do a black veneer) or is it a smooth look like the piano finish, but without the depth of appearance (less shiny too)?  Thanks for the feedback

jsalk

Re: SongTower veneer choices
« Reply #1 on: 7 Dec 2011, 09:36 pm »
For the most part, it is simply a matter of looks.

Bamboo is lighter and stiffer than the MDF usually used to build the cabinets.  Some would say this is a superior material for speaker cabinet construction.  I don't know if I'd go that far.  It is certainly a good material, but I can't say is I've heard any significant improvement in sound quality when working with bamboo.  To me, it is a matter of being a more "green" material and perhaps aesthetics play a role in it as well (if you like the looks of the bamboo).

As for the black finish, most people looking for black speakers are using them, at least in part, for home theater.  So they do not want them glossy.  Satin is a nice alternative.  Satin finish is also what you  normally find on most high-end furniture.  It makes wood look more natural compared to gloss which can look nice, but perhaps a bit plastic.

When we do black, we can do it with a flat surface (which we normally do) or we can do it over oak, ash, etc. and leave the grain open.  Some people like seeing grain in the surface and we certainly don't mind.  You need far less finish if you are not filling the grain.  So having grain show is the easiest way to finish black speakers.

I hope this answers your questions.

- Jim

srb

Re: SongTower veneer choices
« Reply #2 on: 7 Dec 2011, 09:43 pm »
For the most part, it is simply a matter of looks.

When we do black, we can do it with a flat surface (which we normally do) or we can do it over oak, ash, etc. and leave the grain open.  Some people like seeing grain in the surface and we certainly don't mind.  You need far less finish if you are not filling the grain.  So having grain show is the easiest way to finish black speakers.

So are you saying
 
a. If wood grain is not desired, then the black paint finish is directly applied to MDF without any veneer ?
 
and
 
b.  You can have a black stain over oak or ash veneer for the same cost ?
 
Steve

jsalk

Re: SongTower veneer choices
« Reply #3 on: 7 Dec 2011, 10:21 pm »

So are you saying
 
a. If wood grain is not desired, then the black paint finish is directly applied to MDF without any veneer ?
 
and
 
b.  You can have a black stain over oak or ash veneer for the same cost ?
 
Steve

That is correct.  If you want the grain, we simply cut the panels with MDF that is pre-veneered.

- Jim