I generally try to stick with the less abrasive cleaners. This is why I tend to try Wright's first. While Wright's *does* have a VERY slight abrasive added, it is the chemical reaction that actually does the bulk of the "renewal."
You mentioned that the knobs are gray. This indicates the plating has worn through. You are seeing the underlying "pot metal" or "white metal" the knobs are cast from. (Like the parking light housing on a '53 Buick.) Give the Wright's another shot, but allow the polish to contact the surface for 5 to 10 minutes. This allows the chemical time to de-oxidize the part. You can also try Tarn-X and follow it up with a good polishing using Wright's. If this doesn't work, you're *probably* in need of new knobs.
By the way, both Flitz and Simichrome paste are OUTSTANDING products. For plated products, they tend to work EXTREMELY well *if* the plating is intact. If it is worn away, they can also polish the underlying metal, but this *might* not be as aesthetically pleasing. Then again, it might.
Hope this helps a bit.
Bill