The 300

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic. Read 4646 times.

ooheadsoo

Re: The 300
« Reply #20 on: 19 Mar 2007, 04:41 am »
There are unfortunate precedents for naked spartans.
http://www.gtp.gr/LocPhotoAlbum.asp?id_loc=5625&cmd=showd&cmda=2




http://www.goddess-athena.org/Museum/Temples/Sparta/Leonidas_statue_finding.html


http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Jacques-Louis_David_004.jpg


Be glad there were loincloths.  There weren't in the comics.
I quite enjoyed the "giants" and "ogres."  I didn't mind that they were goopy, I find it reasonable for them to be depicted in that way.  It's hot under those immortal masks, after all.  Watch al di meola live in montreux or stevie ray vaughn play at the el mocambo, some time, and they're not even wearing 20lb. helmets.  If we take a spartan for 5-5.5 feet, the "giants" were probably well under 7 feet.  That's not that big a stretch, even discounting exaggeration.  I've read other stories where someone with a severed hand fashions a weapon out of his ulna and radius, so it's not even original.  I didn't notice any "monsters."  Just armored rhinos and elephants.

The movie is actually much better than the comic in just about every way. 

Yeah, the greeks had slaves like 10x their own population, and there was a bigger army with the spartans, and there was a battle for Leonidas's body, and it was a local who betrayed them, not a deformed spartan, and other details, but I don't think this movie pretends to be historically accurate.

PhilNYC

Re: The 300
« Reply #21 on: 23 Mar 2007, 02:57 pm »
Saw this last night, having never read the comic book nor having any knowledge of the actual history of Sparta or this specific battle.  It was entertaining...better than I thought it would be, but also somewhat predictable and overall forgettable.  Throughout the movie, I kept thinking that this looked and felt like a lite Gladiator wannabee...even down to the little details, like the mother/son scenes in the wheat fields, the strong female lead (her speech, her strength, even her look were Gladiator-esque), etc. 

Worth seeing on a big screen if nothing else at the theater looks particularly compelling to you...

Ears

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 712
Re: The 300
« Reply #22 on: 12 May 2007, 12:49 pm »
Saw this one at IMAX and it was pretty good.
I would rate it 4/5 for the actual movie and will probably buy the Blu ray when its released for demo material.