"I wonder if dogs vs cats is similar to LP vs digital?"
I gave up on the whole 'cats vs. dogs' debate a long time ago. My current animal companion is a three toed sloth, named Eddie. You hardly know he's there, but every two months he climbs down from the small trees in my living room to take a shit on the floor. At first this may seem cumbersome, but Eddie is really slow. I never have to chase him around the house, and at least I have enough time to be prepared.
In about twenty years or so, when Eddie finally falls out of the tree in a soporific heap, then I'll know it's time to take him to the vet. How's that for low maintenance?