Great post! Now, do you feel that most high end audio is overpriced, or?
Not necessarily. Stuff like wilson, genesis, kharma, alon (ugh), revel and others tend to be absurd for the sake of it. I read an article about a brainstorming session to price high end products. Even at $40K it would have been high. The manufacturer decided it would sell better at the magic arbitrary number of $100k. I once compared my modest ATC scm-12 to wilson watts (just the top of the watt/puppy). Here we have speakers at least 10x the cost apart. The scm-12 involved me, the focal-tioxid equipped wilson sounded hard and etched, not my bag. I have an article from watchdog (audio perfectionist) that describes how the watt/puppy wasn't just designed to impress rich folks, it was also made to impress reviewers. The focal tweeter "went off like a fire alarm" at 19khz. A speaker that cost $22K that measures poorly and sounds less impressive than a $1,000 speaker. Note that wilson moved on the beryllium tweeters. At least that gives them edge for the $10k-$12K dealer markup. Not my cup o tea though.
Companies like salk, vmps, bryston, magnepan, mccormack, Thiel, vandersteen, vonsweikert, AVA, nottingham, VPI, B&W, Clearaudio and a HOST of others offer what I call fairly (understandably or justifiably) priced high end. That is partly because they are
engineered. They each make products that sound purely musical, win awards and kick the snot out of a lot of those overinflated products. If a company pours it's soul into R&D and HONESTLY engineers (like Richard Dunlavy, Richard Vandersteen, D'Appolito, Nelson Pass, Brian Cheney, John Curl etc) I can understand a certain expense, especially when you get a product adorned in expensive touches (milled chassis, gold plating , marble etc) Ever heard of Hamilton? They use the diaural crossover gimmick and sold a few $14K mini monitors. $14k? GMAFB.
This may sound crazy, but I listen with my ears alone. That excludes eyes, wallet, or genitals. I appreciate fine work and eye candy. But the bottom line is that there are plenty of products that don't cost as much as a house in Nebraska that sound as -good often better- than these cost-is no-object ego inflation devices. On this very board, we have Salk, VMPS, and PLC speakers that offer that level of sound refinement, and manage to do it without the ponzi-scheme prices. They all have technology and drivers that don't usually find their way into sub $12,000 speakers, let alone $2,000 speakers. I have said it before and I'll say it again: these companies only need to formulate some kind of pretentious model name for their speakers, add a shiny corian cabinet and charge $40K-$100K and they will be in the running. Lucky for us, they give us
pure performance that also measures well at an affordable price.
FWIW: I have heard genesis, infinity (remember the irs-III?) Kharma, wilson, krell (speakers, eeew) revel and other snob-approved cost unlimited high end speakers that made me walk out of the room. Yet I have heard displays of the products in the second paragraph and wanted to listen all day. But I don't have a 6-figure income, and I have no one to impress. Therefore I am forced to be objective vs price-oriented. The facts as I see them are that high price is not always attached to superior sound.