Howdy folks!
I have had quite a bit of time to play with the Nexus and it is time for my final write up.
It has been a very pleasant journey and many thanks and kudos for HAL’s continued support!
Goals MetLets start with my original goals and if they were met:
Single volume control for the whole system with a remoteThis was achieved.
I still need to use my pre-amp to manage the many sources I have in my system, but I have that set at 12 o'clock and control the volume through the Nexus.
My turntable is my only true analog source, but the Nexus only has one USB in, one Digital RCA (S/PDIF) and one Analog in to work with.
I am less concerned with Audio Nirvana from my video sources and am happy using the fiberoptic out from my projector, but with no fiberoptic "in" on the Nexus, I am forced to use on of my DACs via the Pre-Amp.
A fiberoptic S/PDIF port would make a world of difference and free up the analog in for me to play with the RIAA functions for my turntable. Not a showstopper, but I think there is a lot of opportunity I will miss in using the Nexus as a phono-stage.
Room Correction for all sources, including analogDefinitely achieved.
My vinyl has never sounded better, and my AV, even when routed through my Topping or Schitt Gungnir has taken on new live. Whether I was watching David Byrne’s “American Utopia”, Roger Waters “This is not a Drill”, Metallica “Through the Never” David Gilmour “Live at Pompeii” or any NPR “Tiny Desk Concert” it was sublime.
The improvement to vinyl was so profound that my wife mentioned it might be time to upgrade my Dennon DL 103 cartridge. I knew what she really meant was that I should buy a Small Audio Manufacturing “Reference” Turntable and a Hana ML cartridge. The turntable is en-route as I type.
I have a collection of around 2000 LPs most of which are Jazz. I am really looking forward to re-discovering them.
This turntable can accommodate multiple tone arms, so having the pre-amp in between works out when I splurge on a second tone arm. I will eventually use my two Parks Audio phono stages (Budgie with step up transformer and the Puffin) to accommodate that.
Move more of the bass to the subsAccomplished.
HAL setup the sub crossovers at 50Hz. So the subs are more in play. One thing to note is that the bass is significantly improved. This is primarily due to the timing alignment. With the Nexus, if I move my subs around I just need to measure the distance from the listening position to the subs and speakers, enter the values into AudioWeaver and presto! it is properly time aligned.
Easy and affordable upgrade pathAccomplished.
This is met in spades. As you may recall from my thread starter, I am using a pretty janky method to connect the amps to the speakers (speaker cables into cheap connectors) as well as using my six channel Rotel amp to drive the mids. Despite these shortcomings I am thrilled with the sound and can only imagine what connecting amps directly to the speakers will sound like. My next goal once I recover from the turntable purchase is to buy a couple of three channel Hypex or Purifi based class D amps and place them directly behind the speakers.
Higher quality DAC for my BluRay playerThis is accomplished.
I can connect my Blu Ray using the RCA S/PDIF directly to the Nexus and as I stated earlier, the DAC in the Nexus is definitely higher quality and an improvement over my Topping D90 or my Schitt Gungnir.
Ability to learn more about sound engineeringOh my, did I learn, and am still learning.
The ability to control all aspects of the signal path with AudioWeaver has opened up a whole world of possibilities. While there are certain things I just wont touch, seeing the end to end chain visually has immersed me into all that goes on in getting the signal just right. The power of being able to add as many PEQs as I want to flatten out the response is not available with any other product I know of. Most DSP implementations only allow for 10 PEQ adjustments, I hear that one Nexus user has over 45 PEQ adjustments flattening out their response. If you have any kind of OCD, the Nexus will not disappoint.
Fun is an expectationOk, this journey is fun. Very fun. Very frustrating at times, but so rewarding once you figure it out and bust through a barrier.
I want to add that HAL was there to help throughout and a big part of what made this so much fun. Again, Kudos to HAL!
As an early adopter, I hope to discover challenges and opportunities that lead to product improvements and solutionsI do not know if Danville Signal is paying attention to my thread, but I do know that HAL has sent a few of the issues we discovered over to them. A few of these concerns should be addressed with the upgrade to more powerful chips.
Anyway, here are the challenges I see with this early version of the DSP Nexus:
•Power on/off and Standby Mode Pop Noise
This is a major concern.
Every time you turn the Nexus on, off or go into or out of standby you get a scary pop to the speakers. You always need to turn off all the amps before turning the Nexus on. This is an annoyance I do not believe belongs in a $3000 piece of kit.
There is another Nexus owner out there with some pretty spendy Beryllium tweeters who rightfully is very concerned as he starts to set up the Nexus.
I really hope that Danville Signal addresses this in the upgrade as I suspect this is something that will keep others from taking this journey.
•FIR Filters are not advised
This should not be an issue after the upgrade, however using these led to all sorts of weirdness from 2 seconds of odd sub rumbles in between songs to very audible distortion in the woofer section. Stick to IIR with the early adopter versions.
•S/PDIF out not working
This is not something that I am overly concerned with right now so I did not apply more than 15 minutes of troubleshooting so could very well be on my end. Danville was informed of this issue.
•Nexus Freezes
This one I figured out.
If your PC/Laptop is connected via USB to the Nexus (which is often the case when playing in AudioWeaver), after re-boot/power on, there is a good chance your Nexus will freeze up. Turn off your amps, unplug the USB and restart. I have yet to burn a final AudioWeaver Design to my unit, so I do not know if that will remediate this issue. I am also of the school of thought that is ok leaving their system on 24x7. I am blessed with very cheap electricity and have never had an issue with any of my equipment as a result to leaving it on.
And of course, I am looking forward to hearing the improvements afforded by active crossoversExpectation met!
Major improvements. The imaging is incredible. A lot of this can be attributed to the better DAC and switching to HAL’s MS-6, but getting the timing right has opened up the system beyond where it ever was.
You know where everyone is on the stage, instruments show up in pinpoint locations, your listening room becomes the room they are recording in. Close your eyes and you are in the studio, club or concert venue. Even less than optimal recordings come alive, it does expose the lower quality, but even then, these recordings are more listenable than before.
All the overused cliche audiophile reviewer buzz words are present, but now I feel like I know what they really mean.
In ConclusionI am
very happy I took this journey. While the Nexus is really a heck of a tool for speaker designers, this is one of the few gems out there for audiophile types that does not have diminishing returns. When closing that final 5% of the way to perfection, the Nexus has provided the biggest jump forward I have experienced with any of my audio purchases.
In my opinion it is the most significant improvement I have made in my 20+ years of chasing audio bliss. It significantly improves everything across the board and gives you the control to take it as far as you want. I am really looking forward to the upgrade and adding hearing what FIR filters can do with the added processing power.
My Test Track ListI wanted to include my test tracks list as I personally am always interested in what other folks use and what they are listening for.
Turboweekend, 'Sweet Jezebel' on Ghost Of A Chance - This tests your room correction and quickly identify any unwanted ringing resulting from your PEQs being wonky. I got this from Obsessive Compulsive Audiophiles (OCA) Test Tracks.
Pink Floyd, 'Time' on The Dark Side of the Moon - I, and 99% of the world know this song so well that any differences stand out. I noticed a whole new level of life and power with the Nexus. Especially in those early bass notes right after the clock chimes.
Norah Jones, 'Little Room' on Not Too Late -Another one from OCA. This makes sure your toe-in/balance is correct. Norah is dead center in this track.
The Beatles, 'Her Majesty (2019 mix)' on Abbey Road (Super Deluxe Edition) - Another one from OCA. If your toe-in/balance is correct then Paul should be walking between your speaker, not in front or behind, but directly in between them.
Henry Mancini feat. Monica Mancini, 'The Pink Panther Theme (extended version)' on Ultimate Mancini - Another one from OCA. This is a great imaging track. Instruments are easy to point out on the stage with this song.
Commodores, 'Nightshift' on 20th Century Masters: The Millennium Collection: Best Of The Commodores - Just a very well Engineered track. I listen to this for hearing how well the different instruments are separated. Every instrument is clear and in its own space.
Herbie Hancock, 'Cantaloupe Island' on Dedication - This is one of the best sound stage tracks I have heard. When he starts going off on the keyboards, the sounds will be all over the room, behind you and down the hallway. Great sound stage test track
Black Sabbath, 'Black Sabbath' on Black Sabbath - Another OCA recommended track. The thunder storm is above and the rain is hitting where it is supposed to hit. OCA believes this is one of the best engineered albums off all time I have no reason to doubt his assesment.
Béla Fleck and the Flecktones, 'Flight of the Cosmic Hippo' on Flight Of The Cosmic Hippo - Great bass clarity track. Victor Wooten reaches deep somewhere around the 2.5 minute mark. Those deep notes are clear and tight when your subs are properly integrated.
Roger Waters, 'Three Wishes' on Amused To Death - This is a great sound stage song. When the system is set up right, the woman's voice at the beginning comes from far left of the speakers, the chorus is above and the genie is powerful and clear
Trentemøller, 'Chameleon' on The Last Resort - This will put all your bass to the test. Most bass issues will show up with this track.
Tool, 'Chocolate Chip Trip' on Fear Inoculum - Sound stage and clarity. The drums roll off to the left and right and around you. On my system they are coming from 4 feet in front and 10 feet outside the speakers. The drums sound like an actual drum kit is in your room. Love this test track.
Willie Nelson, 'God's Problem Child' on God's Problem Child - Good all around test for how balanced your systems sounds. The bass is deep but balanced with the mids and highs nicely.
Jacques Loussier Trio, 'Little Fugue In G Minor' on Jacques Loussier Plays Bach: Encore! - Just a fun track that adds a drum kit to a classical song. Well engineered and you can hear the bow hitting the strings.
Yosi Horikawa, 'Bubbles' on Wandering - If you have not heard this song, it is an auditory adventure. Not an everyday listening song (at least not for me) but the various balls bouncing around is distinct and clear. You here them bouncing and rolling across the soundstage. There is a lot going on in this song and the system should be able to distinguish between all the activity.
Baba Blues, 'Help me through the Day' on Excavations: Blues Is a Rainbow - These guys play through a PA system, so the crunch and resonance on the guitar notes is quite exaggerated and is a great indicator of how clearly my system is dialed in, especially in the mids and tweeters. Very hard to describe, but once you hear it, you will not accept less.
Any Peter Gabriel Track. His music really opens up on a good system. I like "Growing Up", the song is all over the room when you are dialed in. When you are not it can be a little on the blurry side.
Thanks Everyone I hope this thread helps those deciding on trying out the DSP/Active route and provides a little guidance. It is quite a lot to take on, but considering that I successfully pulled it off, then I think anyone can pull it off.
As the marketing states -
"..convert a very good loudspeaker system to a much better loudspeaker system regardless of the initial cost." (this is good segue for HAL to call out what the folks at Magnepan told him during a recent visit at Capitol Audio Fest)
I will leave it at that and happy to answer any questions you may have either here or in PM.