Don't own a CF, nor any AVA. But I do own two tube preamps and 5 tube amps with tube drivers and I have heard differences between the small signal tubes in everyone of them. Sometimes very little difference, perhaps some imagined, but at other times it made a decided difference in some aspect of the sound.
In one preamp I swapped out lower grade Chinese 6DJ8s for Amperex JAN 6922s and the sound opened up along with the treble becoming less edgy. In a Dennis Had-built Inspire amplifier, I swapped out a new, reissue Tung-sol 6SN7 for a vintage Westinghouse 6SN7 (I preferred this tube over 4 vintage Sylvania 6SN7s) and the soundstage became deeper with a more natural, less compressed sound.
In a Conrad Johnson preamp, some 12AU7 tubes were warmer, some had wooly bass, some were more neutral.
At other times swaps yielded no discernible difference, or even had a negative effect. Sometimes I prefer vintage, but some new tubes are quite good.
I would run your new tubes in a bit before conducting comparisons.
What tubes are stock in your preamp?