Hi Rob,
I wasn't denying what you heard, merely the comparison set up...something had to be amiss.
Look at it this way....the XX2 is musically a better cartridge, it just is. The Versalex is not exalting the 20XL over the XX2. I've heard them way too many times in various setups. Nor is the Versalex a better sounding table. It's marketing. I've heard 20Xl's on both the tables side by side, the sound is very similar. Seems a tad lighter to me with the Versalex.
I agree with your assessment of the LP12, although there are pricey mods that diminish that somewhat.
I, too, have heard/read rumors, although I sure hope it's not true. The Amadeus/Amadeus-GTA is still the best of the lot, the rest are just marketing machines - the Simplex at a price point, the GTA for finish and black ball, the Versalex for wood. It will be a great day if Firebaugh indeed makes a table that supersedes the Amadeus, so far the others have been marketing issues.