jn - I appreciate your thoughtful reply. I really do. Further, I get your analogy because I studied the martial arts for almost 10 years. Some minutes ago.... But even assuming that the posts advocating for assessment, evaluation, and purchase, based upon price, manufacturer, specs, whatever, when auditioning isn't possible, gives no indication whatsoever of the level of buyer satisfaction when purchasing in that fashion. As, or more, important, I'm willing to wager that anyone who does purchase a component unheard, and despite any other parameter(s) known, exercises heroic pre-purchase efforts to locate information on how the kit sounds. If such a purchase is not attended by those efforts then I'm willing to argue that the purchaser values sound quality less than the other "known" parameters impelling the buy.
Now, if you agree, then we have to ask, why? Why would a "blind" purchaser undertake such pre-purchase efforts to discover the sound quality? Why? Because sound quality is the primary reason we buy and keep our gear. Or, would anyone argue that audiophiles keep their gear because, although they are bored/uninterested/dismayed with the sound quality they are enamored with the specs, construction, and aesthetics? I'm not speaking to those people.
For us old guys, you may remember a luminary in audio, Harvey Rosenberg (now long passed sadly) who went by the nom de plume Dr. Gizmo. He was, for decades, a fixture in the N.Y. City audiophile society and a brilliant amp designer. He used to write a column in Dudley's rag, "Listener." Full of wisdom: every line. Gizmo had rules re: audio. One that has stayed with me for decades and never led me astray, went like this:
"What's the most important aspect of any amplifier? Tone
What's the second most important aspect of any amplifier? Tone
What's the third most important aspect....? Tone"
I 100% agree with Gizmo. And, you CANNOT assess tone without listening. I don't give a damn what else one "knows" about the gear. One last, and the most important, thing: It is a pleasure "speaking" with you and all the others on this thread. I treasure our conversation. Especially those raising counter-arguments. Don't want a world full of me. Fuck that!